this post was submitted on 01 Nov 2023
705 points (99.9% liked)
196
16303 readers
2010 users here now
Be sure to follow the rule before you head out.
Rule: You must post before you leave.
founded 1 year ago
MODERATORS
The structure of their skulls also resembles those of elephants, so it's possible they also had long trunks.
This is an old theory that is no longer supported by most paleontologists AFAIK. Trunks require specific musculature, more blood vessels, and more nerves than a regular nose does, and those things leave evidence in the structure of the facial bones.
I'm no scientist and I've never seen one in real life, but I can promise you penguins do not have trunks iirc
Snuffleupagus.
Does anyone know if this is something that was actually possible? Like, how sure are we they looked one way and not the other?
“Every reconstruction involves some level of inference and speculation to literally ‘flesh out’ details not preserved in the fossil record,” Celeskey explains. “In the process of creating paleoart, artists and the researchers have discussions about how to fill in these missing pieces, which helps everyone involved to think about how they are interpreting the actual evidence at hand.” From a NatGeo article I found
Tldr: Trust me bro
“I asked around the office and everyone agreed that giving the t-Rex wings looked dope”
Similarly, "I asked around the office and everyone agreed that giving dinos the feathers we now know they had would look too silly"
"Triceratops had cat ears because of reasons."
Nope, sauropods were already right up against the limit of what's physically possible for a land animal on Earth. If they were that chonky they would have been too heavy and would have overheated just from their body heat.
Sounds like skinny dinosaur propaganda to me.
I was in an Avant-funk band called Skinny Dinosaur Propaganda.
Vids or it didn't happen.
Sorry to disappoint you, but it didn't. I made it up as a joke 🤷
My day is ruined
Would it help if I pointed out that your hair looks nice today?
Thanks, I got it on sale :]
Nice! How much was it? I've been looking for a nice looking hair myself but they're outside of my price range!
Check your mammalian privilege.
Signed, dinosaurs.
Of course it's possible. It's highly improbable due to weight, of course, but it's not impossible.
There's a lot of information that was not recorded in fossil, and we have very few fossil recorded, compared to how many animals of a species lived. How we reconstruct existinct animals keeps on changing with every new information, so it's always cool to challenge the way we view a creature.
Not very likely due to the weight. Same with the trunk suggestion, there was a lot of air space and gaps in the few skulls that were preserved to make them weight less.
Is that a long neck between your shoulders or are you just happy to be a skeleton?
Reminds me of an XKCD strip about spiders. A time traveler comes to the present to see a live spider since they only had remains to look at. They're astounded that spiders can make webs.
This honestly reframed dinosaurs for me forever. Science is extremely conservative with its interpretation, but the reality is that we only know very basic details. Millions of years is a long time to develop some really strange physiology.
Your overall point is super valid. Sort of a, "We don't know what we don't know."
However, I think that at this point, scientists have gotten good enough at analyzing skeletons of animals to pretty accurately predict musculature to know what ancient animals mostly were built like. The spider web stuff is things like skin texture, color, were there feathers, cartilaginous frills, etc. It seems like a few times a year I see an article about a feature like that being found in remains, and that's super cool.
C H U N K Y B O Y
Big big Chungus!
Chonkosaurus
I can't believe people care about dumb shit like someone's height in fields where it doesn't actually matter. That 5'1" little brown woman in office with her finger on the big red button is always going to be much more of an actual objective threat than some 6'11" massive chungus of a dude with no real charisma to speak of.
Hell, just give the little brown woman a gun and pit her against Big Chungus on the street and see who comes out on top.
People who analyze each other's body condition and size and prioritize it for everyone other people do are such worthless fucking knuckledraggers.
I don't think you commented on what you thought you did
Yeah, I just realized this is the wrong thread :P It's okay, I moved it. Sorries
At first I thought you were really passionate about not comparing dinosaurs and penguins sizes
Go off, sis
Cuz, but I deleted it. Is the post still showing up for you?
EDIT: I just checked and my comment still shows up for everyone else even though I deleted it. What in the actual fuck? Lemmy is fucking worthless garbage.