The only way for libertarianism to work is if every human had only good intentions. Since thatβs simply never going to happen libertarianism will never work. Just my opinion feel free to disagree.
this post was submitted on 21 Sep 2023
1505 points (91.7% liked)
Memes
45901 readers
1600 users here now
Rules:
- Be civil and nice.
- Try not to excessively repost, as a rule of thumb, wait at least 2 months to do it if you have to.
founded 5 years ago
MODERATORS
Libertarianism is a theory espoused to those with good intentions by people that have bad intentions.
It doesnβt work for almost anyone. But it super works for some. Thatβs the point.
load more comments
(5 replies)
The problem is that it doesn't work even if everyone has good intentions. It needs everyone to agree on what "good intentions" even means.
load more comments
(1 replies)
load more comments
(81 replies)
Zoning for single-family housing is regulation and is done to boost landlord profits at the expense of working people.
The mortgage-interest tax deduction only benefits wealthier households, while giving nothing to poorer households who rent.
There are many regulations that artificially funnel money upward and would be improved by "deregulating" those parts. Deregulation doesn't have to mean removing safety procedures.
If the states and cities legalized dense housing then much poverty would be relieved.
Sure. I don't think anybody is arguing that there is any country that couldn't give their regulations a once-over and improve things by removing a few counter-productive ones here and there.
That's not what American style libertarians are actually arguing when they say they want deregulation though, is it?
That's generally the type of thing libertarians get upset about. Or shit like floral licensing or cracking down on people braiding hair (this is generally black people, obviously) or the bazillion other types of regulatory capture. Farm subsidies and ethanol mandates/fuel subsidies are also a shitshow.
load more comments
(1 replies)
Exactly. It's stupid to be like libertarians and take a hardline stance on "regulations always bad!!" or "regulations always good!!". A regulation that bans building dense, walkable communities is bad and needs to be eliminated. Likewise, regulations that ban teachers from talking about the existence of gay people are also bad and need to be eliminated.
Just like we try to use regulations for good, many others use regulations for ill. It will always be context-specific specific whether we need more regulation or deregulation.
When actual libertarians get a chance to run a town, they don't start by eliminating zoning laws. This is the kind of thing that happens instead.
load more comments
(4 replies)
You talk as if benefiting the ruling class was an unwanted consequence of these laws. Itβs not. The markets need to be free for the rich to benefit but restricted for the rich to benefit. And maybe some crumbs will fall of the table and the poors will think that the rich are so generous.
load more comments
(3 replies)
That's the irony.
But Density means communism to them so they're suddenly fine with regulations and taxes that prop up an unsustainable suburban ponzi scheme because that's the lie sold about the American Dream.
When they see how unaffordable housing has become they say, "good, my house is more expensive."
The difference is that they think that gatekeeping poor people from services in order to bring costs down for everyone else is valid. I've seen libertarians argue that the solution to tuition and healthcare being expensive is to stop helping poor people, because that will drive demand down and lower prices for people who can already afford it. I've seen libertarians argue that the solution to people scalping groceries is to let grocery stores price gouge. Their solutions only ever involve helping people who don't need help at the expense of people who do. Libertarianism is "me, me, me right now now now" dressed up in fancy language. It's the political philosophy of a tumor.
"It's the political philosophy of a tumor." Fantastic analogy!
Libertarianism is a great system if you're using it as a backdrop for a cyberpunk dystopia.
load more comments
(2 replies)
load more comments
(3 replies)
βWe live in a societyβ - the jonkler
βNot if I can help itβ - libertarians
load more comments
(2 replies)
Being Libertarian means never having to admit youβre a Republican
Libertarians are just Republicans that want to smoke weed.
Be fair. Some of them are republicans who are more open about not wanting age of consent to be a thing.
load more comments
(1 replies)
load more comments
(1 replies)
As far as I can tell, the ones with money want a free hand to do whatever they want to others without repercussion, and the ones without money are willfully drinking the Kool Aid and being led around by the nose philosophically.
load more comments
(2 replies)
Typically they argue the government is the cause of the problems (which is frequently correct) and the solution is to remove regulations that create the inefficiencies (which rarely goes to plan and frequently involves enriching them).
It's clownish just for different reasons than the meme suggests.
Their solution to an inefficient fly swatter is to get rid of it, spread honey over every surface, and offer to sell their services as an exterminator.
load more comments
(1 replies)
load more comments
(1 replies)
You ever hear a libertarian complain about flying? Fascinating one-person debate about airlines and deregulation.
Believing Libertarians argue in good faith. π€‘
Thats cause if they argue in good faith they wont be Libertarians for long.
Most "libertarians" are this dumb, but the old school ones at least attribute the problems to uneven regulation rigged in favor of the ruling class, which does jive with my understanding of what is wrong with the financial system. That being said, libertarianism wouldn't work even if they did get shit straight.
The vast majority of libertarians are (in my experience) just conservatives that want to smoke weed. They believe a lot of the same awful shit. The rest of them have deluded themselves into thinking that a libertarian society is viable when it is laughably not. They generally consider themselves to be way more capable and independent than reality can support.
load more comments
(10 replies)
How is it that free market's modus operandi seem to be attempting suicide every few years?
It's not free enough!!!!
No joke, though, there are people who think that letting things hit the wall as fast and hard as possible is desirable. It's called accelerationism.
load more comments
(2 replies)
load more comments
(1 replies)
I've seen them claim that a natural monopoly cannot exist and that monopolies we see today are all enforced by government regulation.
load more comments
(6 replies)
i thought being a libertarian was cool when i was 20 and wanted to smoke weed but didn't know how to get any
North America has never been a free market. Even since the days of Sumer have there been regulations on commerce. We will never have a free market.
load more comments
(6 replies)
Zoning codes that restrict density are the opposite of a free market.
load more comments
(2 replies)
view more: next βΊ