Yet another win for Systemd.
Target disk mode is fantastic, I'm thrilled to see this coming to Linux
this post was submitted on 31 Oct 2023
329 points (95.8% liked)
Linux
45859 readers
2293 users here now
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Linux is a family of open source Unix-like operating systems based on the Linux kernel, an operating system kernel first released on September 17, 1991 by Linus Torvalds. Linux is typically packaged in a Linux distribution (or distro for short).
Distributions include the Linux kernel and supporting system software and libraries, many of which are provided by the GNU Project. Many Linux distributions use the word "Linux" in their name, but the Free Software Foundation uses the name GNU/Linux to emphasize the importance of GNU software, causing some controversy.
Rules
- Posts must be relevant to operating systems running the Linux kernel. GNU/Linux or otherwise.
- No misinformation
- No NSFW content
- No hate speech, bigotry, etc
Related Communities
Community icon by Alpár-Etele Méder, licensed under CC BY 3.0
founded 5 years ago
MODERATORS
Worked in IT, target disk mode is a life saver when you have to recover data from a laptop with a broken screen/keyboard/bad ribbon cable and don't want to take apart something held together by glue.
It's a nice feature. I used it a few times on old Macs with external FireWire hard drives for booting a different OS or troubleshooting.
Soon we'll be debating whether we call it systemd/linux or gnu/systemd.
Red Hat: "we put the D in your System"
I'm happy that this is coming to linux (I believe Nutanix has a great method to expose storage over IPs), but I would have liked if this was a bit more project/dependence agnostic.
I mean, it specifically is giving support for booting disks over an existing protocol to systemd. That's pretty well within scope?
Oh, my gripe is not with Poettering creating a systemd service for it (for I cannot dispute that systemd wrappers such as this does make life somewhat easier), but I would have liked perhaps a more distribution agnostic method of running NVMe-TCP in a way that the OS would not have to be booted. I suppose I do understand the community's support for this: systemd is used by most of the popular distributions, and writing a service in it will enable systemd to maybe interleave this between other processes and perhaps fulfill the goal of producing a block device on an L3 network without booting userland.
As one can probably surmise, I do not have a great understanding of how the process works - will have to figure out how MacOS did it first, and then about how Poettering implemented it. I think I'll have a better idea of what the solution is geared towards.
Thanks for your comment!
I would have liked perhaps a more distribution agnostic method of running NVMe-TCP in a way that the OS would not have to be booted.
From the pull request:
This all requires that the target mode stuff is included in the initrd of course. And the system will the stay in the initrd forever.
I think that's as minimal a boot target as you can reasonably get, or in other words you're as far away from booting the OS as you can get.
So now the question is whether this uses any systemd-specific interfaces beyond the .service and .target files. If not, it should not take much effort to create a wrapper init script for the executable and run it on non systemd distros.
Thanks, that makes it easy to understand. Indeed, it doesn't seem very dependent on systemd, which is great. I was aware that the project existed, and for a second thought that Poettering was trying to integrate it directly within systemd somehow whilst making improvements to it. I suppose that's not the case, which is good.
And you're correct, that is probably the easiest way to boot the minimum required resources.
Thanks.
load more comments
(1 replies)
Oh, another arm growing.
Link to the post (for accessibility and follow-up in the thread): https://mastodon.social/@pid_eins/111324093735348164
Pull request: https://github.com/systemd/systemd/pull/29748
This seems like a win for almost all distros
Yay, yet another storage protocol over the network.
Not a storage protocol over the network, but yes :P
“ via NVMe-TCP (in case you wonder what that is: it's the new hot shit for exposing block devices over the network, kinda like iSCSI…”
So….?
The protocol already existed. This made it convenient to boot from it
load more comments
(3 replies)
Can someone eli5 pls?
"target disk mode", which this claims to be taking a lot of inspiration from, pretty much turns your computer into an external harddrive - so you can connect another machine to it for direct access. This appears to be trying to accomplish the same, but over the network.
If you've ever stuffed up a machine so badly that the best idea you could come up with, was to take the harddrive out and work on it from another machine - this pretty much allows you to do that. But instead of taking the drive out and putting it an external drive enclosure, you just ask the stuffed up machine to act as the external drive enclosure.
Great answer
Oh okay. Thanks for the simple explanation :)
same, i have no idea what any of that means and i use runit
runit gang !
You assessment isn't entirely correct as this is indeed related to systemd. Read the PR https://github.com/systemd/systemd/pull/29748
@TCB13 services aren't systemd-related just because they are launched by systemd.
A service by itself shouldn't be systemd, it should be implemented separately and run under systemd. However, this is using the systemd target subsystem which is a little more specific.
Exactly my point. Thanks.
load more comments
(4 replies)
From what I see in the repo, this functionality is being built into systemd (in the same vein as something like systemd-resolved), and introduces a new target dedicated for the new feature.
Sure, you could probably rip it out and use it with your own init system, but that seems tedious to now scour the documentation to ensure your init system brings up the 'dependencies' launched at the preceeding systemd targets, so the NVMe TCP service can run.
Would be easier to just use another existing implementation IMO, most people running their own init systems probably want more than the bare minimum featureset offered by the services included in systemd's package
load more comments
(1 replies)
Is this like booting over pxe? Is nvme tcp widely supported on motherboards?
No, this has nothing to do with your motherboard. Once you reach the boot menu you'll be able to pick your OS and alternatively systemd-storagetm. If you chose the the latter then your disks will be available to other machines over NVME-TCP. Just like Apple.
The problem of keeping comparing and doing analogies with apple shit stuff is that many of us have no idea what tech of magic apple does, so saying things like "just like apple" is a completely useless phrase that gives zero info whatsoever about anything.
It's probably why we're getting the tech almost 20 years late. Apple started doing this with FireWire
So I could mount and chroot over TCP to fix problems? Looks a little more complicated at this point than fstabbing an iscsi target, but I imagine that'll improve. https://access.redhat.com/documentation/en-us/red_hat_enterprise_linux/9/html/managing_storage_devices/configuring-nvme-over-fabrics-using-nvme-tcp_managing-storage-devices
Sweet.
The PR aims to make it easy and simple.
So when it's booted it will just advertise the storage to the LAN over nvme-tcp protocol?
Not "booted", you won't be booting your full OS. It's just an option on the boot menu that launches systemd and a small program that does the magic and nothing else.
So share drive / simplified NAS, no?
Kind of... but you're directly accessing the hard drive like iSCSI does. Way less latency, no high (and slow) protocols like SMB are used.
NVMe/TCP is an extension of the NVMe base specification that defines the binding of the NVMe protocol to message-based fabrics using TCP. The rules for mapping NVMe queues, creation of NVMe-oF capsules, and the methods used to deliver the capsules over the TCP fabric are described in the NVMe/TCP Transport Specification. By binding the NVMe protocol to TCP, NVMe/TCP enables the efficient end-to-end transfer of commands and data between NVMe-oF hosts and NVMe-oF controller devices by any standard Ethernet-based TCP/IP networks. Large-scale data centers can use their existing Ethernet-based network infrastructure with multilayered switch topologies and traditional network adapters
- https://infohub.delltechnologies.com/l/nvme-nvme-tcp-and-dell-smartfabric-storage-software-overview-ip-san-solution-primer-1/what-is-nvme-tcp/
- https://nvmexpress.org/wp-content/uploads/March-2019-NVMe-TCP-What-You-Need-to-Know-About-the-Specification.pdf
- https://nvmexpress.org/answering-your-questions-nvme-tcp-what-you-need-to-know-about-the-specification-webcast-qa/
SAN. Not NAS.
But is it running at the same time as a an OS or is it just a device without an OS running, sharing storage?
So NAS without any controls. Yay?
trivial to set up NAS with minimal overhead, plus you can boot any pc into this once it's standard, which would be nice for rescuing when you fuck something up: rather than fiddle around with rescue mode or digging out the drives you just boot into this mode and access the drives from your laptop or whatever.
load more comments
(1 replies)
So like, grubd boot menu? And from there I can boot over a location on my nas for example? I set up ipxe a couple weeks ago but it couldn’t load over my thunderbolt to 10g nic. Would this help?
So this is a service aimed at exposing disks as nvme-tcp boot targets on boot of the system? I mean I love it, I wonder if this could be used to help with a chicken and egg problem I've had with building clustered systems easier. So far I either need a running service to host a network file system (like NFS or CEPH), or I need local disks that bootstrap the clustered storage environment.
view more: next ›