Technology
This is a most excellent place for technology news and articles.
Our Rules
- Follow the lemmy.world rules.
- Only tech related content.
- Be excellent to each another!
- Mod approved content bots can post up to 10 articles per day.
- Threads asking for personal tech support may be deleted.
- Politics threads may be removed.
- No memes allowed as posts, OK to post as comments.
- Only approved bots from the list below, to ask if your bot can be added please contact us.
- Check for duplicates before posting, duplicates may be removed
Approved Bots
Suggesting discord as a competitor to reddit is dumb when discord does not pop up in search results containing information that may provide the solution. Might as well call WhatsApp a competitor to reddit then.
That's not all people used reddit for though. I'm also absolutely devastated about the amount of generational knowledge that lives on reddit right now, and sad that some of the biggest contributors of that have probably wiped their accounts by now, but for alot of the community aspects of reddit, and finding groups with similar interest, discord does perfectly well.
For socializing discord can match it, but it's really more the database of information that is searchable and viewable by anyone who doesn't even use reddit and it not being gatewalled that makes Discord not even come close. It's too much of a closed ecosystem even among discord account users with having to be in a particular server to benefit, and servers have been shut down and information all lost for members too.
Socializing to me is secondary. Like when it comes to stackoverflow, xda, or whatever random forums pop up in searches it's really the solution that's at the forefront of importance than whether these users are friends or whatever for anyone trying to find a relevant answer to their problem.
Great article, but it does miss one point IMO. Some fights are more important than others. Pao became unpopular among extremists who wanted to be allowed to push hate speech and discrimination. Funny the article didn't mention the revenge porn debacle.
That actually resulted in the Voat fork of reddit, which of course quickly became a cesspool, and ended up failing.
The fight Pao fought was necessary, for reddit to have a shred of respectability, and to even stay legal, and for reddit to not fall into a hole of hate speech and idiocy. Pao took the fall for decency, and was forced to leave. But AFAIK none of the things she did were reversed, because they were necessary.
What Steve Huffman is doing is not necessary, on the contrary it's thoroughly documented to be harmful to reddit as a service in general, and especially for mobile users, and even more so for people who are blind.
There's an enormous difference in the importance of the Hill Pao died on, and the hill Spez chose. However the article is pretty spot on about the difference in how the 2 situations are handled, and how Spez is actively making it worse.
He's trying to get a bag selling off the company his two smart buddies made.
I agree with most of this article except about Discord being Reddit's main competitor. I think Discord has a distinct enough feel that it's almost kinda separate from other social media. It's less so like a platform you make posts on and moreso a big text group with lots of features, which is perfect for some communities but stifling for others.
I don’t really get a lot of what people want to use Discord for. A couple web forums I used (ram by companies, for specific games) closed and they moved to Discord. How is IRC-style chat a replacement for a forum? They’re totally different formats.
While I do like discord. It is like you say a completely different format. Shouldn't be compared to reddit.
It just doesn't work for anything other than playing games together IMO.
Works well enough as a group chat / voice call app. That's what it's for. Before discord you had to pay for good group voice calls.
ya, just op was saying people are trying to turn it into a chat hub and it's just not worth. If I want to text my friends I'll just text them in a group chat.
It's good for things like support chat or quick questions.
To be fair, they have Forum Channels.
That is an improvement for sure. The problem remains, though, that the info is locked in Discord and won't show up on search engines.
Oh, that's kinda neat actually.
Yeah, the only problem is that even a forum channel would require you to create a Discord account and find that server before you can even see its content and that's just not acceptable for massive open communities like r/malefashionadvice that seems to be moving to Discord.
Yeah, I'll be sticking with Lemmy anyhow but I have to admit it's a cool feature
I think discoverability is still a problem.
I use Discord for real-time communication, but leaving a platform that's closing up access for a platform with already closed access makes no sense to me. It doesn't solve the original problem.
Yeah, that's a pretty dumb comparison. Discord is a chat, reddit is a forum. They're fundamentally different.
I believe the kids call it "shitting the bed".
Damn, I forgot about the Victoria Taylor controversy. Brings back some memories
Hes busy roleplaying Nero, just finishing the touches on the costume now.
Drugs, obviously.
well worth the read, I didn‘t know about the IPO background until now
and now I know where Durmstrang originated