Now it's a matter of sustaining and slow growth. Hopefully. Best thing you can do to see Lemmy succeed is participate: comment, post, doomscroll All+Top Hou ;)
It'll take a while for some of the smaller communities to get critical mass. And that's okay, probably. Critical mass is here for the larger topics already. I'll do my best to help :)
I’ve been pretty happy with the content actually, what do you think is missing?
Not the person you asked, but so far it feels like I see more memes here than I did on Reddit. I don’t see a lot of news, and the communities I was subbed to on Reddit are not active here at all. That includes communities based around running, hiking, nature, and female fashion advice for example.
I have blocked most of the meme communities and all seems just fine to me now.
This helps, but ideally lemmy should make some changes that give smaller subs more equality with bigger ones in the sorting.
Right now even if a small community is active, it just gets drowned out by the bigger ones, even in your subscription feed.
I think they are working on tweaking the hot sort a bit more to make it more representative so the huge communities don't drown out the smaller ones especially in subscribed
Or some equivalent of a multireddit where you can look at some quiet communities as a block.
The memes are currently overshadowing a lot of other content types, due to how the hot sorting works. Even if a small community is active, it doesn't make it to your front page because its votecount doesn't compete with those of a bigger community.
The "best" sorting type which I hope will come eventually, aims to address this by including one post from each community, before including a second, etc.
This should help small communities which still have activity, to be seen more. Currently, I'm having to go look in smaller communities manually, to see if there are new posts.
Is there a GitHub issue I can follow for this sorting?
https://github.com/LemmyNet/lemmy/pull/3378 and https://github.com/LemmyNet/lemmy/issues/3622
I find Top - Day to be my favourite sort, even though Hot is much better. I've also subscribed to enough communities that my default is Subscribed + Top - Day or Subscribed + Hot. I'll often dip over to Local, but rarely All. Only downside of the Top sorts is that the shorter the time span, the higher the ratio of cute animal pics. Scratch that, it's not a downside.
Point being, that once you have enough active communities subscribed, that seems to be the best. Local is good if you are on an instance that meshes well with your interests.
BTW, I'm on Lemmy.ca, so Local will show me news from across Canada usually.
Using top sort like this is not even close to a solution.
I want to see posts from a community with ten subs, that get ten upvotes, meaning that post was really good for the people it was for.
Top will never show that. It will show posts that got a hundred upvotes first even if that sub has ten thousand users, meaning relatively, it was a worse post.
My point is that I WANT to see content from small less active communities. How else are they supposed to grow? Even my subscriptions are bad, never showing me all that I want to see.
I hear that, yeah the interest-specific communities haven’t caught up yet for sure. A lot of them have only a handful of posts if they do exist.
Definitely a lot of memes, but I feel like I am seeing a good amount of news though? Actually I feel like reddit was getting to be pretty spotty about news, there were a couple weeks I used both and lemmy consistently showed me the headlines much sooner.
I browse in compact mode on memmy and scroll past the memes usually fwiw, so it may just be a matter of my perception
Nor most of the local/regional communities.
I was on Reddit a lot to see chatter about games I enjoy. The presence of Destiny 2 or Diablo 4 players seems pretty quiet on Lemmy. A lot of game devs are on Reddit and I don't know how many of them have or will move to another platform.
Porn. Copious amounts of it in particular.
Lol, reddit used to be the same way actually, it was only relatively recently they removed porn from the front page.
There’s a toggle in your profile for it, and apps like Memmy have an additional setting to hide those posts just while you’re browsing the app