Don't black boxes have beacons of some kind?
I'd also imagine an airtag is useless in this scenario as if it crashed and no one knows about it, it's likely not near someone's Bluetooth enabled phone either.
this post was submitted on 18 Sep 2023
700 points (95.2% liked)
Memes
45190 readers
2012 users here now
Rules:
- Be civil and nice.
- Try not to excessively repost, as a rule of thumb, wait at least 2 months to do it if you have to.
founded 5 years ago
MODERATORS
Uhhh...
F35 is a stealth aircraft. Beacons are literally against the point of the damn thing.
People are asking 'How could you lose your invisible car? Why didn't you just put a tracking device on it?'
I'd imagine it's something that can be turned on and off, just like it's stealth technology.
Edit: to further expand on this, finding the downed plane is a lot more important than it sounds. This could technically be classified as spillage considering there is classified tech in an F35. Foreign agents would benefit if they found it first. I'm pretty sure there are recon teams trained to recover downed aircraft in military zones. Considering they still are equipped with radio for communication, I'd imagine even just an encrypted message at time of impact could be useful.
Losing a plane over friendly zones shouldn't have to worry about having a beacon that's always on. I fail to understand why it would be silly to believe one could be useful in a jet fighter, stealth or not. I'd imagine it's likely even present but just defunct for whatever reason in this scenario and details can't be revealed about that, as again, it still contains classified technology.
F35s have transponders, just like every other aircraft that flies in the US. They are necessary to avoid mid-air collisions. When flying a stealth mission in enemy airspace, they can turn the transponders off.
Unfortunately, the transponder on this particular F35 is not working.
They also turn them off for a number of other reasons.
Sure, but the point is they have transponders. And pilots generally use them (because it's safer) unless they have a good reason not to.
So once its on the air the jet has zero comms? That doesn't seem right
Ever heard of a concept called "Radio Silence" ?
Why can everything else can be turned off when needed but not this? Surely "the pilot ejected" would be a good moment to start knowing what's going on with the plane
load more comments
(7 replies)
They still have them but because of course they do. They can be turned off easily enough. I'm not sure what sorts of modes they have when ejecting. I could prolly find an AF tech and ask.
i feel like a beacon on a military jet would be counterproductive if the jet were to fall on enemy land
Do they not put beacons on their seats either? How did they find the pilot? I'd imagine if it were an issue, it could be deactivated in wartime or over enemy lines.
They can turn them on/off depending on their needs. I'd imagine you train exactly how you'd fly.
Even on home turf it's not great if the enemy/terrorists can find out where your equipment is. Pearl Harbor was on US soil.
Obviously it would be nice in this specific scenario, but how often would that really be useful in comparison to the potential security issues that comes along with it?
the airtag won't do anything if there are no iphones around
Telling people to be on the lookout for an F35 won’t do anything if there’s no people around.
Satellites?
You’re right, I shoulda sent my satellite to the area to search for it.
Mr. US Government, I presume?
Can you tell that to my Android phone that nagged me for 4 days straight about the AirTag hidden in the rental van I used for a trip through France? Was fun trying to drain the battery by making it bleep throughout the trip though.
Depending on the application you used to alert you of the AirTag, it's possible that your phone did not send location data back to Apple.
Apple can track AirTags, because iPhones are programmed to listen for them over Bluetooth Low Energy, and send the ID of the AirTag and location data of the device to Apple.
If your Android phone has an application to listen for BLE devices in the background, keeping track (locally) of which devices it saw in what locations, that application can tell you if you're travelling with an AirTag (or similar device). It might even be able to interact with the AirTag, such as making it beep or reading its ID. If that application doesn't send your location to Apple, the AirTag was not able to use your phone to make its location known to the owner.
Therefore, to the owner, AirTags are useless unless an iPhone (or other device that sends its location to Apple) is around.
The dollar sign goes on the left.
This is a German meme. They use Megadollars because of the metric system.
They actually just call it a royale without gps
Putting the dollar sign in the left or right, decidollers or megadollers... Decisions, decisions...
Well isn’t that just the state of politics today.
right side dollar side gang $$$
Nice
It's currently doing some Flight of The Navigator stuff with some kid in Noth Carolina.
What happened to my brain?
It leaked.
Link without paywall: https://archive.ph/bagfn
The guardian doesn't have a paywall
Maybe not, but it still shows this:
That's not a paywall. A paywall is basically a mechanism that locks content if you don't pay.
I should have called it a pay hedge.
My main complaint is that the message is so big, and that it covers so much of the screen.
Edit: I forgot to mention that I dislike sites suggesting a monthly donation my default.
So click the X
Don't wanna.
They do after you read a few articles.
No they do not, subscription/registration is optional to people that can read.
An airtag won't work if its under enough water.