77
Players are accusing Tencent’s latest game of copying Sony’s Horizon series
(www.videogameschronicle.com)
Wow. Two reddit users call a game a rip-off.
Journalism
this post was submitted on 28 Nov 2024
77 points (88.1% liked)
PCGaming
6578 readers
23 users here now
Rule 0: Be civil
Rule #1: No spam, porn, or facilitating piracy
Rule #2: No advertisements
Rule #3: No memes, PCMR language, or low-effort posts/comments
Rule #4: No tech support or game help questions
Rule #5: No questions about building/buying computers, hardware, peripherals, furniture, etc.
Rule #6: No game suggestions, friend requests, surveys, or begging.
Rule #7: No Let's Plays, streams, highlight reels/montages, random videos or shorts
Rule #8: No off-topic posts/comments
Rule #9: Use the original source, no editorialized titles, no duplicates
founded 2 years ago
MODERATORS
I wish mods would remove posts/ban users who just post click bait bullshit..
Report it. That's how you make sure they're aware of it.
I did :-)
If a different company can make the same game, but better, then more power to them. They'll have to overcome the wall of players that "dont want to play another horizon" as well as innovate to make it feel fresh.
If someone made a copy of legally-distinct bloodborne it would do beyond amazing if enough effort and love was put into it.
All of this to say, if the game is a cash grab with tracky drm or microtransactions then its not going to do well if it is like that PLUS a 'rip-off' of another game.
Just don't preorder and see if its a cash grab first. Extremely difficult for some i know.
Well it's going to be free to play so expect lots of garbage monetization
Tencent owns Digital Extremes as of a few years ago, and last I knew its monetization wasn't too bad. So maybe there's a slim chance they'll take a lesson from that?
I'm sure that's a stretch though since DE built up their payment model many years prior and were bought when they were already successful with a large playerbase. A new franchise is likely a very different story.
Yep. Tencent has a major share in Path of Exile too and that game is beyond generous being f2p with no p2w.
I remain cautious but optimistic for all games. There's nothing wrong with being excited. Just dont buy into stuff without proof and you wont be disappointed.
At worst, it's just not what you thought it'd be and you dont buy/play it.
Yeah, remains to be seen but even Palworld got flack for copying Pokemon's style even if it was a good game which I enjoy. I saw an article just a bit ago where the palworld developer was interviewed and he stated he felt he was still under the shadow of the AI copying accusations.
Still like you said, it's one thing to copy an art style, another to actually make a good and compelling game.
Yeah looking at the art and screenshots they showed I could definitely mistake it for a Horizon game.
Ok. Did they do it better?
If it’s an improvement, I don’t really care if it’s a copy.
From the trailer I saw it looks like a hybrid of Horizon, Monster Hunter, and Dragon's Dogma. If it's free to play it's almost guaranteed not to be single player, so there's that as well.
Honestly I was kinda disappointed when horizon turned out not to be the "monster hunter with robots" I thought I saw in the trailers
Zero Dawn was great, I'm definitely happy to see more games with the same vibe.
Imagine if after Doom, no one else was allowed to make another FPS, yet alone a space shooter.
Imagine if every FPS after Doom has the exact same art style as Doom.
They did for a while.
Maybe this is selective memory but I remember the old dos days differently.
Outside of your capstone games, gloom, and Super Noah's Ark, I seem to remember, most successful clones had their own style.
Hexen, red neck rampage, duke nukem 3d, dark forces, rise of the triad, had unique art styles even when limited by current level design.
Are we looking at the same artwork?
Exactly. Doom-clones are what made modern FPS possible.
and yet china claims to be winning and winning. LOL. the chinese youth will have a hard time with no good jobs. but hey, xi is ruler for live...so good for the rest of the world because china invents nothing of relevance these days. yes, they steal like chatGPT but their conclusions are worse. i for one welcome china to keep failing at everything. if you have no citizens being able to think free, you'll have to keep on copying.