this post was submitted on 27 Jul 2023
533 points (98.5% liked)
Curated Tumblr
3976 readers
885 users here now
For preserving the least toxic and most culturally relevant Tumblr heritage posts.
Image descriptions and plain text captions of written content are expected of all screenshots. Here are some image text extractors (I looked these up quick and will gladly take FOSS recommendations):
-web
-iOS
Please begin copied raw text posts (lacking a screenshot that makes it apparent it is from Tumblr) with:
# This has been reposted here to Lemmy as part of the "Curated Tumblr Project."
I made the icon using multiple creative commons svg resources, the banner is this.
founded 1 year ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
I don't think it was in the 2003 version, so it might matter which version you watched. But it was the notes Ed deciphered which let him know that Philosophers Stones are made of people
Spoilers!
Sorry to break this to you, but it's been like... Twenty years? Dang, I feel old...
Hah you're good I actually watched the original series when it came out.
Been meaning to try Brotherhood, I don't read manga so would be interesting to see the difference. But it's a heavy investment for a show I've sorta already seen.
The OG FMA was made while the manga was still coming out, they caught up with the source material and went a different way with the story. Brotherhood is what the creator intended for the anime to be. I always recommend Brotherhood over og if someone has never seen FMA.
I usually recommend people watch 2003 FMA up until episode 9 or so, and then switch to Brotherhood once it reaches the divergence point. Brotherhood is absolutely amazing and one of my favorite shows of all time, I consider it a comfort show that I'll occasionally rewatch because of how much I love it, but it DOES kind of rush through the early parts that were already done in order to get to the good stuff.
To give you an idea of what you're in for, where the story was in episode 30 in the original, they get to in episode 10 in Brotherhood. The story gets way different very, very quickly.
That's why I don't recommend watching only Brotherhood without watching the original. Brotherhood assumes you've seen the original so if it were your first time it rushes through the first act and doesn't develop the characters enough
I also highly recommend Brotherhood
You can always just skip a few episodes. I don't know how many, but I'm sure someone online can tell you where to start if you've already seen the original
You haven't seen it. The part of the story the first anime covers is only a small part of the second. After it outran the manga, it also had to completely wing it. Brotherhood is a much more traditional shounen thing, but I prefer it to the first one, which I think sort of jumped the shark.
Soundtrack was fucking awesome, though.
I watched the OG and brotherhood. Brotherhood is a different show completely. Not as 'slice of life' / chill as the OG, a lot more big plot turns though because its in step with the manga.
Brotherhood is a masterpiece, definitely worth a watch, especially if you liked anything about the worldbuilding of the 2003 anime.
And Edward is great in 2003, but in brotherhood he becomes one of the Titans of excellent character development and character arc, right up there with Prince Zuko.
I haven't gotten past the first season of Avatar, heh. Its on the list and I have enjoyed what I've seen but also can't binge it.
There's enough extra content that it's just as engaging to watch.
Ngl I've always hated that reasoning. It's really inconsiderate to younger people. Sure, The Hobbit has been out for ages but somebody just turned thirteen yesterday and might have only just discovered it. I know I would've been upset if it was spoiled for me just because it came out before I was born.
Edit: You downvoters are pathetic tbh, it’s just a common courtesy that takes no effort. The speech equivalent to the shopping cart test. All you have to do, before saying the spoilers, is just to say "spoilers for example" and then you get to talk about whatever you want and not be a complete asshole to somebody who hasn't been exposed to the same media as you. Be better.
So what, we can never talk about the ending of any story/movie/game because someone hasn't been born yet?
Technology gave us spoiler tags and unmarked spoiler warning on communication spaces. So, sure we could, if we wanted to --shrug
Would it be so hard to just say you’re about to mention spoilers and then talk about whatever you want? It’s just a common courtesy that takes no effort. We even have spoiler tags if you want to go the extra mile but that's not even necessary. Just say "Spoilers for Example Property ahead" or something like that and then that's it. You can talk about what you want and still be courteous to people who haven't had the same media exposure as you.
Or just note that you're about to talk about spoilers? Is that so hard?
Seriously, that's all you do. Just say you're about to mention spoilers and then talk about whatever you want. It's just a common courtesy that takes no effort.
Also the nationwide transmutation circle. It's shape reveals that many of Amestrus' past military actions were actually part of a grand conspiracy. Hughes figures this out.
The whole country's shape and history is part of a literal recipe.
There's also the bit where Scar's Brother's notes have a the counter circle hidden on the back.