asksciencefiction

303 readers

1 users here now

Have a question about a fictional universe? Ask it here!

Rules

1-Please tag your post with the fictional universe you are asking about. e.g. [Star Wars] or [Marvel Cinematic Universe].

2-Only questions about fiction are allowed. Real-world questions are better suited for a question and answer community

3-Any fiction is allowed, not just science fiction. General questions not related to one specific universe are allowed.

4-Roleplaying is not mandatory, but all answers should ideally be framed from the perspective of the fictional universe being asked about.

5-Above all else, be kind and considerate to others. Remember, if you are not building this community up, you are tearing it down.

founded 1 year ago

MODERATORS

Furbag

MathiasTCK

[Harry Potter] Why don't mages use subconscious magic when they get their wands? (self.asksciencefiction)

submitted 1 year ago* (last edited 1 year ago) by T156 to c/asksciencefiction

2 comments fedilink hide all child comments

One of the ways that you can find out whether a child has magic or not, is to see whether they are able to use it subconsciously, such as by defenestrating them, and seeing if they stop themselves from being killed. But once they get their wands, that use of subconscious magic seems to stop entirely.

Logically, you would expect students to fire off similar magic when their lives were at risk, or their emotions ran particularly high. Is it a function of having the wand that stops it, or is it just a matter of that only happening for really young mages, and that they learn to control themselves as they enter childhood?

all 3 comments

sorted by: hot top controversial new old

[–] Jumper775 3 points 1 year ago

I think you will find that the answer may or may not have something to do with pickles.

[–] capt_wolf 3 points 1 year ago

Its been a while since I've seen the movies, and I've never read the books, but here's a wiki article that explains it a bit.

It's basically summed up as an unpredictable instinct in young children. I'd guess that maybe that's lost as they get older and can think more concretely. Probably adding wand foci and being drilled in using then so much in Hogwarts also diminishes that innate ability. It seems that as you become more dependent on foci, the more difficult and unpredictable wandless magic becomes.