Its 31% Rotten Tomatoes score puts it behind misfires like Star Trek: Insurrection (55%), Star Trek: Enterprise (56%), and even the much-maligned Star Trek: Nemesis (38%).
Hopefully saved you a click
this post was submitted on 24 Jan 2025
36 points (100.0% liked)
Star Trek
249 readers
7 users here now
An inclusive place for all Trekkies
Rules:
1: Be polite: the Federation solves its problems with diplomacy.
2: Be relevant: This is a place to discuss Star Trek and things related to it.
3: Be mindful of spoilers. Wait 1 week after the airing of an episode to discuss it outside of spoiler threads.
founded 2 years ago
MODERATORS
Oh, so I can even more safely ignore this than usual.
Insurrection was banger.
Enterprise wasn't nearly as bad as everyone made it out to be and I'm sorry I took so long to watch it. Just don't ask me to listen to the opening.
And honestly I only dislike nemesis because... Well, you know....
Enterprise certainly had its moments, but the whole Xindi arc was bad. It finally found itself in Season 4 once it shed those shackles.
For me, it was Archer using any, and every, excuse to talk down to T'Pol. I'm not sure who was writing his character, but I would've preferred if they'd gone more towards Picard (TNG) or Pike (SNW), and less Kirk/Sisko. As the first human explorers in that part of space, I would preferred more reverence for what they were accomplishing, and less whining about Vulcans. The other characters were were way more enjoyable to watch
TNG and SNW captains brought/bring a sense of awe with their exploration of the unknown, Archer just seemed like a kid who's parents told him he couldn't have ice cream for dinner
I liked that the xindi were a bunch of different species
And they were all too stupid to not see through the Suliban plot
What 'Star Trek' Project Had Worse Reviews Than 'Section 31'? Longtime Star Trek fans won't be surprised by this one: it's 1989's Star Trek V: The Final Frontier. [...] The result: a 23% Rotten score and the rest of the franchise avoiding any reference to it for decades.
It’s time for a new show runner for Trek.