asksciencefiction

303 readers

1 users here now

Have a question about a fictional universe? Ask it here!

Rules

1-Please tag your post with the fictional universe you are asking about. e.g. [Star Wars] or [Marvel Cinematic Universe].

2-Only questions about fiction are allowed. Real-world questions are better suited for a question and answer community

3-Any fiction is allowed, not just science fiction. General questions not related to one specific universe are allowed.

4-Roleplaying is not mandatory, but all answers should ideally be framed from the perspective of the fictional universe being asked about.

5-Above all else, be kind and considerate to others. Remember, if you are not building this community up, you are tearing it down.

founded 1 year ago

MODERATORS

Furbag

MathiasTCK

[Ace Attorney] Why are spirit mediums treated as fake, when they are a very real thing? (self.asksciencefiction)

submitted 4 months ago by T156 to c/asksciencefiction

2 comments fedilink hide all child comments

In our world, the police going to a spirit medium for the DL-6 case, and being ridiculed might be logical, since spirit channelling isn't a real thing, but in the world of Ace Attorney, it is.

Not only is it a known and established practice, with detectable physical effects, but the monarchy of at least one country is specifically sought out for their spirit-channelling powers by other governments, so that they can commune with the dead, and receive advice that way.

However, it also seems to be disbelieved, and ridiculed as a pseudoscience, despite that.

top 2 comments

sorted by: hot top controversial new old

[–] [email protected] 4 points 4 months ago

The easy answer is because the plot of ace attorney isn't very serious, and the events happen because the plot demands they do, such as the law that dictates all trials must end in 3 days.

The hard answer (which is never explained but makes some semblance of sense and is my head cannon) is that Redd White controls the media, and has crafted the narrative that mediums are unreliable specifically to create blackmail material against the prosecutor and Misty. It is unknown if the general public believed that spirit mediums are unreliable before the Misty case, but you could construe that not really, and that White has manufactured public opinion in believing that it is.

As a side note, there are plenty of proven techniques that are not viewed as acceptable sources in court in real life too, however here it most likely is because the game doesn't want you to be frustrated that you couldn't simply solve all cases by going to a spirit medium.

[–] breadsmasher 3 points 4 months ago* (last edited 4 months ago)

I wrote a detailed response before realising this is askscience fiction and the world in discussion is Ace Attorney. Not the real world