That video was fantastic.
this post was submitted on 27 May 2024
216 points (97.8% liked)
Star Wars
4676 readers
77 users here now
Discussion for all things Star Wars. Movies, books, games, TV shows and more are welcome.
1. Keep it civil.
2. Keep it Star Wars related.
3. No memeposts. Memes are great and everybody loves them, but there is already [email protected] for those.
Community icon art from DeviantArt user DavidDeb.
Banner art by Ralph McQuarrie.
founded 1 year ago
MODERATORS
Lol she is hilarious.
This is a 4 hour Magnum Opus, and it's broken through, to Jenny Tok, memes, NPR, The New York Post, Forbes, hahahahahaha
Jenny Nicholson has made a vibrant career out of this, i mean have you seen the literal thousand person list that is her patreon, on her patreon, lol, that's not even including the adsense money she gets from the tens of milions of views on youtube.
Jenny is better at video essay breakdowns than i will ever be at anything in my entire life.
She's a little woodland sprite, with an Einstein brain, who loves star wars, disney, theme parks and plushies, she doesn't care if we like them or not, but is overjoyed at sharing her knowledge, experience, and deep background research for just about anything that turns her on. As evidenced by her success, most of us remain supremely grateful for it, and eagerly await the next time she deigns to grace us with her content.
I'm a big fan.
It's weird how much you focus on how much money she makes.
It's an odd post, but I have to admit I had the same fascination. I remember finding out that she exists when the YT video I was listening to ended and, before I got my phone out of my pocket, it had auto played some girl introducing the story of a LARP theme park I had never heard of. An hour later I was heavily informed about the tale of Evermore despite giving no shits about theme parks.
I listened to a couple more of her essays on topics I have no inherent interest in, then took a closer look at her channel. I thought, I'll add her to my Patreon list for awhile, I've gotten several hours of entertainment. Queue the holy shit when I ran the numbers.
Sometimes people make good stuff, and then they are financially rewarded for that. Good for her.
Edit: English better.
I just think it's incredible, I was watching her years ago, and was amazed, and to see the growth in people being drawn to her content, on subject matter they don't even particularly enjoy, just to watch her talk about it, has been so very enjoyable. I added her numbers because it's a benchmark of the success I am so pleased she's experiencing.
Oh, no doubt she's fantastic. Her Vampire Diaries essay is still my go-to for background viewing. Even now the China Beach ad gives me giggles.
It's just strange to focus so much on how many millions she may make when in reality she's got almost no merch and uses copyrighted material in her videos that probably prevent a lot of monetization. She doesn't have millions because most YouTubers with her following have sponsors, ad reads, and patreon call outs. She doesn't even say "like and subscribe" or say shit to generate comments. She goes against all advice on how to make a living from a channel and it works. So focusing on how much money she must have seems really antithetical to her channel.
But great to see she is getting mainstream attention! Hopefully her videos will affect change at Disney.
you may be right, i'll delete that shit now
I'm a big fan.
I'm a very big fan.
You literally are.
I think it was a fantastic video. Yes it was extremely long, but like someone else said it was broken up into 20 parts, so I could watch it over several days. It was great to be able to see what the experience of Galactic Star Cruiser was really like, now that we cannot experience it for ourselves.
While you are not wrong, that is kind of her thing long form video essays. So I'm socked people are surprised by the length. But I guess not many people on this side of the internet knows her.
YouTube has a feature where it will remember where you were up to on a video if you stop watching before the end.
I used this feature to watch this video over several days. When I felt like I'd watched enough for one sitting, I stopped watching, then later I started watching again from where I left off.
Yes. I'm being facetious.
The big critical piece mentioned is just some marketing fluff without any receipts or analysis. Calling the hotel “a 48-hour movie that passengers were actually a part of” ignores the entire video. “Every part was designed for enthusiastic interaction” ignores valid criticism of most of the building. I’m not really sure that it really “was proven that the price was indeed worth it” given that the only evidence was TripAdvisor scores, only one of many forums for such ratings. The rest is just strawman bullshit.
It's lazy PR leftover from their initial prep of what consumers would take issue with, re-released using a sock puppet working-class Disney employee pleading for sympathy.
I’ve been wanting to watch it, but 4 hours seems a bit… overkill. Is there really 4 hours of unique content or does it become repetitive or overly granular?
In general, I'd call it roughly 4 hours of unique content. Many themes are repeated, and perhaps some parts are longer than they need to be, but I loved every second of it because it's always either clever, funny, or interesting the whole way through. It's also broken out into like 20 parts, so there's stopping points roughly every 15 minutes, and thus doesn't feel too daunting to get through (at least to me)
It is granular, yes. But it is presented in a very orderly fashion full of perspective and done in a really entertaining manner! I hardly felt the time passing until my stomach growled xD
I watched it at 2x speed, so it cut it down to 2, which is much more reasonable. The pace of the video is fairly slow, so 2x speed is perfect for it. I do think the video is worth the watch though. 4h? Idk. Definitely 2 though.
It is worth it. I was also skeptical, though if you play it on shorter 30' sessions, feels like an opinionated documentary. There are slow parts though by the end, but I'm still glad I checked and the author is an authority in theme parks.
It doesn't feel repetitive, no.
She's goes into great depth and her conclusions near the end don't really land without the context of the full video. I watched it at 1.5x speed and missed nothing.
For me, I clicked on it to see what it was about. I have never watched one of her videos before. I enjoyed the 30 minutes I watched but then I saw how long it was still to go and noped out. I'm sure it's still good but I don't have time for that.