this post was submitted on 28 Dec 2023
36 points (92.9% liked)

Dungeons and Dragons

11125 readers
29 users here now

A community for discussion of all things Dungeons and Dragons! This is the catch all community for anything relating to Dungeons and Dragons, though we encourage you to see out our Networked Communities listed below!

/c/DnD Network Communities

Other DnD and related Communities to follow*

DnD/RPG Podcasts

*Please Follow the rules of these individual communities, not all of them are strictly DnD related, but may be of interest to DnD Fans

Rules (Subject to Change)

Format: [Source Name] Article Title

founded 2 years ago
MODERATORS
36
submitted 11 months ago* (last edited 11 months ago) by Knitwear to c/dnd
 

Bonus points:

What are some interesting takes/interpretations/ reflavours that you've seen or want to try?

top 24 comments
sorted by: hot top controversial new old
[–] [email protected] 16 points 11 months ago (4 children)

Not a backstory quirk, but I have a fun alternative mechanic for a Druid!

I have a Druid PC in the campaign I'm running right now who's still relatively new to DnD and was disappointed that Wild Shape is limited to just twice a day (the DnD movie might be partially responsible for this). After some discussion we came up with some homebrew rules that she's happy with and I've really enjoyed too.

She chooses two animals per day that she can Wild Shape into and she can switch between them and her human form as often as she'd like, but their HP doesn't reset and if one of them hits 0, she loses that Wild Shape for the day. She doesn't have to choose them at the beginning of the day, but once she's transformed into an animal, she's locked into that animal for the rest of the day. So if she decides to transform into a cat to be sneaky at the beginning of the day, she loses out on a possibly big beefy meat shield later on. She also can't choose the same animal twice.

It's been a fun way of giving her the flexibility to go in and out of animal form during RP (and sometimes a little in battle) without feeling like the balance is thrown way off.

[–] Knitwear 4 points 11 months ago

I love that, good on you both for finding something that works for your table

[–] [email protected] 2 points 11 months ago* (last edited 11 months ago) (1 children)

I am playing a druid, the RAW interpretation is a bit boring and relegates wildshape to a secondary ability (in my opinion) when it should be front and center.

I have changed the mechanic to be more similar to sorcery points or ki points.

You get 4 WS points per druid level (+8 points if mood druid)
Transformation is the CR x 4; min 1 point
Time in the form is 15min per point.

So for a mood druid transforming into a dire wolf (CR1), it would be 4 points to transform, and 1 point for the first 15 minutes. Spending a minimum of 5 points; out of your initial 16 point pool at level 2.

Non-moon druid transforms into a cat (CR 1/8), would cost the minimum 1 point to transform and 1 point for the first 15 minutes. Spending a minimum of 2 points; out of the 8 point pool at level 2.

The points still reset on a short rest.

At level 4 when non-moon druids get CR 1/2; the non-moon druid has 16 points; the moon druid has 24. At level 6 when a moon druid gets CR2 transformation they have 32 points. A CR2 transformation costs a minimum of 9 points for the first 15 minutes.

I like this because it means that wild shape becomes a resource to be used and managed like spell slots/ki points/sorcery points etc.....it also seems more progressive, as you become more experienced as a druid you can do more with the wild shape.

It also avoids the "wasted" wild shape feeling, so instead of thinking is it worth transforming into a rat to follow this target through a sewer, when I could become a crocodile later to mess up what they are heading toward....I think, rat for the next 30 / 45 minutes is only 4 points total, leaving me with 12 points in my pool because I was a horse an hour ago.

[–] [email protected] 0 points 11 months ago (1 children)

@absGeekNZ @Goofy Not bad, but feel that the time would come back to bite you. Also, most players I know hate keeping track. Think you could just double to cost, and make it infinite time?

[–] [email protected] 1 points 11 months ago

That is a good idea, I'll give it a try

[–] Witchfire 1 points 11 months ago* (last edited 11 months ago)

disappointed that Wild Shape is limited to just twice a day

Wild shape is twice per short or long rest, not twice a day. A short nap wiill give you both uses back.

[–] owenfromcanada 1 points 11 months ago

I think I actually like the mechanics of this better than RAW. It would fix how broken the Moon druid is, at least.

[–] [email protected] 9 points 11 months ago (2 children)

I played a sort of gutter punk druid once. He'd grown up in a sort of nature commune that had been wiped out by a magical disaster, and had lived penniless and transient on the streets of cities for years afterwards. There was a deep, empathetic anger at the injustices of how the world was structured I really enjoyed playing. Rather than just some reactionary defense of nature as something separate from people, he knew a better world was possible for the people who lived in it too by finding harmony with nature.

[–] Wootz 5 points 11 months ago* (last edited 11 months ago)

Huh. That is honestly brilliant.

Makes me want to play a sort of Hunter S. Thompson druid. He had seen the promises of a better world that the hippie culture in San Francisco in the 60s was all about, and for the rest of his life resented politicians, and by example Nixon, for destroying.

[–] Knitwear 4 points 11 months ago (1 children)

That's some heroic hero feels right there

[–] [email protected] 5 points 11 months ago (1 children)

Yeah, I think he was one of the most unambiguously heroic characters I've played. He was always willing to sacrifice for what he thought was right and just, and constantly put in situations where that put him at odds with the lawful side of the good equation. The DM loved to throw us into challenging ethical situations and I always had so much to bite into having such a well defined and nuanced morality for the character.

For some reason when I write overtly heroic characters like that they don't seem to be that compelling, but then in actual play they really hit.

[–] Knitwear 4 points 11 months ago

It's a tone that can be hard to play well, it's easy to become Lawful Cautious or Party Dad, but you seem to have navigated it artfully

[–] derekabutton 9 points 11 months ago

The zeitgeist with DND druids has always bored me. I play them exclusively evil, as I am finding out just as I think about it now.

There is a middle finger of vecna druid archetype that allows for unique shapeshifts into an abomination. It's a lot of fun to play and the shapeshift options are very versatile and adjustable each shift. I role played a LE human who sook out expediting the heat death of the universe for the Eldritch pantheon. I joined the party as they were already doing a good job leading to the destruction of society. It was all for the purity of nature, of course.

Another I played was a spore druid who was basically Shaggy from Scooby Doo, but evil. The archetype I used was absolutely awful but it came with lots of good stories as I got incredibly high irl to play the character. I conspired with the DM against the party for the glory of Strahd for an entire year of play, and then abandoned the vampire lord when the party started winning the final fight. Convincing the party irl (who was none the wiser but absolutely hated my character) that Strahd was just trying to get in their heads to split the party will probably be my favorite memory of DND for all time.

[–] [email protected] 7 points 11 months ago

Gus watches from his hunting perch. He knows that the prey is there. He can smell it, hear it... He's just waiting on his hunting partner to fulfill his end of the deal. Gus could easily handle this on his own, but when training a companion, it pays to be slow, especially when dealing with the limited capabilities of your "chosen" "assistant." Rodge was neither Gus's first choice (second third or fourth either), nor was he a particularly capable assistant, but somehow Rodge seemed to make the choice, which is against the order of things. Regardless, Gus was stuck with who he had, and all things considered, there were some unexpected benefits to Rodge. Who would have expected the talons? Claws? ("What are those things called in this case? I've not seen digits that function that way often," Gus thinks to himself) would be so damn useful? Sadly though Rodge was absolutely terrible at sneaking and seemed almost blind most of the time. "At least he is able to take commands well enough to distract our targets, maybe one day he will be more useful than startling birds out of the undergrowth while hunting, and it's not as though I need him to carry me around and rub my tummy with those...! Fingers, they're called fingers!"

Gus Gato the awakened bobcat and Rodge the useless human ranger, druid companion pet

[–] [email protected] 7 points 11 months ago

I never had a chance to play him before I switched off of 5e, but I had an idea for one in my back pocket forever. It was a Circle of the Land (Arctic) Druid who talked in an exaggerated Canadian accent, used a hockey stick for his sheleleigh, and wildshaped into Canadian animals like beavers, moose, and goose.

My entire playgroup (including me) is Canadian, so I feel like we all would've gotten a good laugh out of that.

[–] cjoll4 6 points 11 months ago

My favorite druid was a Wizard / Druid (Circle of the Land) multiclass. From a role-playing perspective I didn't really differentiate between his wizard spells and his druid spells - he was a "hedge mage" hermit who taught himself how to work magic. He used a component pouch because that covered all the non-scarce spell components for both classes.

From a gameplay perspective, he wasn't very powerful because his access to higher-level spells was delayed. On the other hand, he had a WIDE variety of lower-level spells. He was able to cast most level-appropriate ritual spells from both classes, always had a utility spell ready for any situation, and Arcane Recovery + Natural Recovery meant he almost never ran out of slots. He was a good versatile caster.

Oh, and he was a goblin who used Disguise Self to pass as a gnome whenever he visited civilization.

[–] Aielman15 5 points 11 months ago

Not mine, but once heard of the concept of an undead spore druid with fungi inside its body that serve as its digestive system.

It was a novel idea.

[–] Manifish_Destiny 5 points 11 months ago (1 children)

Ooh. I'm playing a circle of spores druid with no memory. He just crawled out of some primordial ooze one day. Wild shape is limited pretty hard when you've only seen half a dozen animals. I see him as a thing birthed from the heart of the forest as a protector, but he sees the world as a plaything. He's slowly leaning into criminal tendencies with no alignment to hold him back, and no guidance from the roots that bore him. He made friends with some symbiotic vines at some point as a homebrew feat. It's kind of fun to use the vines in flavored ways with a lot of the druid spells.

[–] Knitwear 3 points 11 months ago

Love reflavouring spells and abilities as plant-kinesis (phutokinesis?). If they won't give us a plant bender we'll make our own

[–] reversebananimals 5 points 11 months ago* (last edited 11 months ago) (1 children)

My favorite ever Druid was a human named Cleetus Fernbottom. I modeled him after the idea of the swampbenders in Avatar: The Last Airbender.

He was middle aged, balding, spoke with a Southern accent and was about as wide as he was tall. He was from the swamp and loved all the critters there. But he was tricked into leaving for a life of adventure because his Druid Circle thought he was too dumb. He wasn't the brightest, but he had a heart of gold.

Mechanically he was a Cirlce of the Moon Druid, and I mostly used Thorn Whip as my cantrip and Giant Toad as my wildshape. His primary function was CC.

[–] Knitwear 2 points 11 months ago

The wildshape options may be labyrinthine but options like the Giant Toad are so fun

[–] kusttra 2 points 11 months ago

While it never got much past the concept phase, I think it would be fun to play a circle of stars druid as a magical girl. I was thinking this ancient elven man who learned a bit of the druidic magics of his people, but was always more fascinated with the stars. One day he connected with a group of gnomes who invented a flying machine that could take them to the moon, and immediately signed up for the trip. When he got there, he discovered a moon goddess that had been trapped there. They hit it off famously, he offered to help free her, and she turned him into a knight of sorts, giving him the transformation ability. When he transforms, he turns into this young, bubbly, vivacious eleven woman with crazy armor and the standard anime oversized weapon that is based on which form he transformed into. She still has all the same memories, ideas and goals, but with a completely different personality. It would be pretty entertaining.

[–] [email protected] 2 points 11 months ago

I played a Druid a few years back whose magical focus was narrowly on stone and earth. The idea was her culture (from which she had been exiled years prior for failing to fulfill some of her clerical responsibilities) considered the world to be a huge grave, and her role in said society was to interact with and advocate for the decomposed and petrified remains of the long dead. So she considered herself something of a necromancer, just for the dead that are so far gone as to become the landscape. 5e isn’t built to support this interpretation of the Druid class, but we managed it with some minor reflavoring and homebrewing. It was a fun concept but her beliefs and goals ended up becoming too at odds with the rest of the party, so I retired her to avoid friction.

[–] Witchfire 1 points 11 months ago

I've been playing Elenath, a 500 year old Stars druid for about two years now. She was originally a priestess of a god of light (though a recent revelation uncovered some arcane truths) until a cataclysmic event shook the world and severed her connection. So she fled to the woods and looked to the cosmos to reconnect with her fey ancestry.

Playing a 500 year old character is really fun because she was alive for anything involving a History check. Though she's rather disconnected from the modern world and is unaware of anything that happened in the last few hundred years.