this post was submitted on 12 Feb 2024
714 points (95.9% liked)
Political Memes
5451 readers
4446 users here now
Welcome to politcal memes!
These are our rules:
Be civil
Jokes are okay, but don’t intentionally harass or disturb any member of our community. Sexism, racism and bigotry are not allowed. Good faith argumentation only. No posts discouraging people to vote or shaming people for voting.
No misinformation
Don’t post any intentional misinformation. When asked by mods, provide sources for any claims you make.
Posts should be memes
Random pictures do not qualify as memes. Relevance to politics is required.
No bots, spam or self-promotion
Follow instance rules, ask for your bot to be allowed on this community.
founded 1 year ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
Nobody said Rafah was safe. They said go south, it will be safer than the north.
And Israel still warns people before airstrikes. They call them on the phone even
13,000 children are dead idk why ur still trying to do this. They bombed civilian targets, they have absolutely no excuse for that. Even if they are still warning people with phone calls, (which is doubtful considering that gaza doesn't have super reliable electricity and connectivity, and most of the people in rafah aren't from there so israel might not even know where they are) Israel still isn't allowed to just blow up people's houses without actual proof that the military importance of bombing said house outweighs the fact that it's civilian infrastructure. Same with mosques.
They use the cell phone network to locate phones, then they send calls and texts. You can usually find recordings and screenshots after an airstrike.
Of course, the media basically never reports on it.
If there is a tunnel under the building, that's not a civilian target.
Ok, I'll be waiting here for evidence that there were tunnels being used by hamas under every single one of those homes, and that israel was using bunker busters to actually destroy them. But I don't expect i'll ever get that, because Israel consistently lies about this stuff and then just waits for people to forget it instead of backing up their claims.
Israel doesn't owe you anything.
And when they do release proof, you say "Jews are liars."
See how that works? There's no reasoning with your type.
Israel does have to prove that they didn't commit a horrifying war crime. Cmon.
Also its ridiculous that you're falling back on calling me antisemitic. If India did the same thing in Jammu and Kashmir, or Russia did it in Ukraine, I would also not believe any proof they presented until it was verified by a third party. That's just basic critical thinking skills.
They don't have to prove it to you, only to itself, maybe its allies. If there's a valid military target and they take reasonable caution to minimize civilian casualties, it may still be horrifying but it's literally not a war crime, and saying it is despite admitting that you don't have the evidence doesn't make it so.
In my view, the IDF is way more credible than Hamas.
Ok, can Russia also provide itself with evidence about Ukrainian forces being in civilian infrastructure to justify leveling an apartment?
Is that what Russia claims when it does so? My recollection is that usually Russia offers no explanation or they deny their responsibility; they'll say like, oh we were struck some military targets, but that apartment building was hit by Ukraine's own missile defense system. Another difference is that Ukraine doesn't have any sort of interconnected tunnel warfare system, let alone one that runs underneath every major city; it would be incredible to say that there were military tunnels under all these apartment buildings. Further, you can see from the Russian attacks that the missiles are frequently launched twenty or thirty at a time, and many of them don't hit anything at all. Seems like it's actually indiscriminate, intentional targeting of civilians: chiefly, I'm not aware of a single attempt by Russia to warn civilians before an airstrike, have seen zero screenshots and heard zero audio recordings of warnings. Ukraine is also credible when it says "there was no military target," unlike Hamas, which incredibly denies everything. Again, if you throw a dart at a map of Gaza, you're pretty much going to hit a tunnel: 400 miles of tunnels with 5,000 shafts in an area that is 25 miles wide at its widest point.
Russia doesn't usually explain or elaborate that much. They just say "we only target military targets, whether obvious or disguised" and then shoot a missile at an school or something, killing civilians. And they could be telling the truth, because Ukraine has used civilian infrastructure like that before, but Russia never provides evidence that the specific school was used that way. This is pretty much the Russia/Ukraine equivalent of the tunnel system, bc you have valid military targets around/in some civilian infrastructure, but Russia ends up just bombing everything.
You also mentioned russian attacks being "actually indiscriminate", but half of the bombs that Israel has dropped on Gaza have been unguided, so that seems like it's also indiscriminate.
Also, according to this amnestly international report (https://www.amnesty.org/en/latest/news/2024/02/israel-opt-new-evidence-of-unlawful-israeli-attacks-in-gaza-causing-mass-civilian-casualties-amid-real-risk-of-genocide/), there are a lot of cases where Israel isn't actually warning civilians before leveling their houses. They also say "Even if Israeli forces had intended to target legitimate military objectives in the vicinity, these attacks evidently failed to distinguish between military objectives and civilian objects and would therefore be indiscriminate. Indiscriminate attacks that kill and injure civilians are war crimes."
So yeah, it's not really debatable that Israel is committing war crimes. Stop trying to run defense for them.
There is no Russia/Ukraine equivalent of the tunnels. The Hamas tunnels are unprecedented in world history. Russia and Ukraine are both legitimate countries with legitimate governments.
Amnesty has no credibility anymore unfortunately. It is Hamas that has a duty of distinction, but it doesn't usually wear uniforms and hides its fighters, weapons, and infrastructure right under people's homes, hospitals, and school. Ya know, because it's an illegal terrorist organization and in no way a legitimate government/state? Has Hamas ever once prosecuted its own people for war crimes? No, but it does stone people to death for being "collaborators." Why don't you stop trying to run defense for literal terrorists, designated as such by a few dozen different countires?
Ok lmao.
It's funny how Amnestly always loses all credibility when it's reporting on a genocide. Same as all the other organizations you don't think are credible anymore... Funny how when Israel reports things, they aren't "just reports" but ground truths, except for the ones that were so undeniable so you had to do a tongue-in-cheek admission... and when the Palestinians and their human rights organization report on it, it's just a "report"....
Please, don't kid yourself like that.
Come on... grow out of this, please... they don't minimize civilian casualties, and there is never a valid military target. Were all the dead babies in incubators a civilian casualty Israel tried to minimize by shooting all the doctors? Serious, get a fucking grip. And it doesn't matter what links I'd send you because you'd either say they are (1) "just reports"; or (2) look terrible and bloody but are totally not a war crime because you trust the IDF more than your own braincells.
Do you have like some kind of personal investment with Israel? You got my head scratching... how can you be reasonable about anything else in life, but when it comes to Palestinians being butchered, you just claim they were "reports"?