this post was submitted on 22 Sep 2023
127 points (98.5% liked)
Baldur's Gate 3
6284 readers
65 users here now
All things BG3!
Baldur’s Gate 3 is a story-rich, party-based RPG set in the universe of Dungeons & Dragons, where your choices shape a tale of fellowship and betrayal, survival and sacrifice, and the lure of absolute power. (Website)
Spoilers
If your post contains any possible spoilers, please:
- Use the text [SPOILER] at the beginning of your title, do not include any spoilers in the title.
- Use the appropriate spoiler markup to conceal that content in the body of your post.
Thank you!
founded 1 year ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
Probably for the best, since the whole thing is a gimmick fight and it needs to be winnable. Though I will say that having it all planned out and seeing my target avoiding it and choosing to attack from behind me, directly opposite where he was supposed to be if I had any hope of killing him, was one of the most memorable moments of that battle.
The amount of ice in my veins when I had to lure the damn thing into place by climbing on the forge myself and just hoping I could run really fast before I had to bring it down on my own skull or he got wise and fucked off.
I can see the necessity, it was just...adrenaline-inducing.
Not a dnd player, is there a tabletop basis for this? Being able to summon Scratch in battle simply because he is a good boy but not being able to call a companion animal when doing so is your whole class feels weird to me.
Not gonna lie, I kinda wish they just wouldn't even touch Gale. You'd think it would get in the way and I get that they technically should fix it because his behavior wasn't the devs' intention for the kind of person they seem to have wanted him to be, but how he's acting has actually added a lot to his personality to me.
Gale is unintentionally incredibly realistic as a Nice Guy,™ enough for me to recognize it instantly for what it is and build my perception of him around it, and his worst trait is being a walking teachable moment. Pointing to how uncomfortable Gale makes everyone literally helped me explain on a more visceral level how "fun" it is to put up with irl to someone last night.
He just sat alone in his tower for years with no normal interaction, so now his judgement is off and he makes a ton of sometimes insane assumptions because you didn't leave him to die and asked him about his cat once and now he won't stop. Even in the middle of the Shadowlands, he's entirely, awkwardly inappropriate for just zero reason.
Withers commented that I'm in a relationship now, and even my character had the option to brush it off as one night spent with a friend, just two buddies talking about magic, 6ft apart because it's not like that.
And I mean, I really didn't notice it wasn't a thing games ever did before I saw others pointing it out. Because between Astarion's dramatic fuckboy attitude and whatever tree Gale and his unholy libido are hiding behind, that's just how guys react to me when I talk to them. I didn't notice it was weird.
Please don't make Gale entirely normal, the jokes are hilarious and he's actually really believable without inherently being unlikable.
Except it is winnable without the Crucible. There’s even an achievement for beating Grym without using the Crucible at all.
It’s much harder to do it, but it’s not an unwinnable fight.
Running around the area everything makes it very clear you need a hammer and heat. I showed up to that fight prepared. Then I saw the achievement pop up, and after I read it I couldn't help be laugh. I did the equivalent of doing the math problem wrong but getting the right answer.
I've killed him on both my runs without using the crucible. The second one was on tactician. Def takes a lot of planning but doable!
I had no idea the crucible was even usable for that, wasn't telegraphed at all. I found the buff/debuff to be infuriatingly inconsistent and eventually the lava mechanic just broke altogether and the only way to leave that zone was to fast travel out of it, and I could never return.
I fought Grym and it did not even occur to me to lure him into the forge hammer at all. Just suffered through only one character being able to really damage him because he had a bludgeoning weapon. My partner was so bored. Then we beat it and got an achievement for killing him without using the forge hammer and lost our fucking minds. On second play-through, tried the hammer thing and he just would not fuck around with the middle of the platform at all, so I, again, just had to bludgeon him to death (but I came prepared and had bludgeoning damage on all my melee characters this time, lol).
Honestly, it's a neat idea for a fight, but it feels so out of place to have a mechanically scripted fight were you have to learn boss mechanics to do it "right", all alone in the middle of a sea of loosey goosey "how do you want to do this" amazing nonsense fights.
That fight took me so long, used up all my health potions, healing spells, a couple of haste scrolls and still only won because somehow, SOMEHOW Gale (the only remaining alive character) hit him with his quarterstaff for like 2hp before the weakness from lava wore off.
When I found out you could just smash him with the forge I was both immensely upset at myself and incredibly proud.