RPGMemes

So tell me. Why specify it in Reincarnate and not in Revivify then ?

I also checked True resurection and it also specifies that the souls needs to be willing.

The answer is this : WotC fucked up.

But I agree, the DMG does says this. Buuuuut. Since some spells mentions willing souls and Revivify dont, I would say that this spell is so fast that the soul cannot decide since its probably still hanging around and so you could use it AT MY TABLE as a way to bring back a soul, willing or not.

But RAW you are correct. Still gonna use it my way as long as everyone agrees at the table. Its not like its gonna break the game.