this post was submitted on 03 Feb 2025
-17 points (9.5% liked)

Political Discussion and Commentary

301 readers
173 users here now

A place to discuss politics and offer political commentary. Self posts are preferred, but links to current events and news are allowed. Opinion pieces are welcome on a case by case basis, and discussion of and disagreement about issues is encouraged!

The intent is for this community to be an area for open & respectful discussion on current political issues, news & events, and that means we all have a responsibility to be open, honest, and sincere. We place as much emphasis on good content as good behavior, but the latter is more important if we want to ensure this community remains healthy and vibrant.

Content Rules:

  1. Self posts preferred.
  2. Opinion pieces and editorials are allowed on a case by case basis.
  3. No spam or self promotion.
  4. Do not post grievances about other communities or their moderators.

Commentary Rules

  1. Don’t be a jerk or do anything to prevent honest discussion.
  2. Stay on topic.
  3. Don’t criticize the person, criticize the argument.
  4. Provide credible sources whenever possible.
  5. Report bad behavior, please don’t retaliate. Reciprocal bad behavior will reflect poorly on both parties.
  6. Seek rule enforcement clarification via private message, not in comment threads.
  7. Abide by Lemmy's terms of service (attacks on other users, privacy, discrimination, etc).

Please try to up/downvote based on contribution to discussion, not on whether you agree or disagree with the commenter.

Partnered Communities:

Politics

Science

founded 5 months ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
[–] FourPacketsOfPeanuts 0 points 1 day ago* (last edited 1 day ago) (3 children)

I suspect your efforts here might be wasted

Lemmys collective view amounts to i) Israel is deliberately, capriciously, methodically committing genocide "isn't it obvious" ii) anything Hamas does is Israel's fault iii) the solution is "obviously" for Israel to make peace with a group consisting of some 25,000 psychopathic islamic extremists.

Lemmy's plan for extremist Jews and Arabs to coexist is... wait.. it was around here.. somewhere.. where's it gone?...

(Downvotes if you can't articulate a plan, please)

[–] [email protected] 4 points 23 hours ago (1 children)

We (including you, unless you'd care to share some credentials) are all laymen here. Therefore, the logical thing to do is to look to the opinions of experts. The experts and scholars generally agree that Israel is committing genocide. The article even admits that (in the sentence I quoted above). Are you, like the article's author, suggesting that your expertise trumps these experts and scholars?

[–] FourPacketsOfPeanuts 1 points 19 hours ago* (last edited 18 hours ago)

I agree with their findings, it bears all the hallmarks of genocide. I just find it a bit pedestrian for the report (or anyone else) to not deal with the overall narrative when making that conclusion. Specifically, that what Israel inflicts on Gaza is disproportionate and illegal. Yet it perversely remains under Hamas' control too. Not a feature of your usual genocide. Does anyone seriously doubt the situation wouldn't immediately improve if Hamas surrendered and returned hostages? That doesn't justify Israel inflicting high collateral damage, but it remains true. Israel punishes the population because a proportion of the population are Hamas jihadists. That's unambiguously against international law. But it wouldn't be happening if Hamas wasn't holding 150 civilians hostage after invading Israel and murdering 1700 - which is also against international law. Calling for Israel to stop what it's doing is a necessary intervention but is pointless if it doesn't also find a method to make the instigator return their civilian hostages.

[–] [email protected] 3 points 23 hours ago (1 children)

It's not genocide because...an internet discussion group can't come up with any solution?

That's taking the goalposts and shoving them off the cliff.

[–] FourPacketsOfPeanuts 1 points 23 hours ago* (last edited 23 hours ago)

They're connected. Lemmy can't come up with a solution because there isn't a solution. And because there's no solution, any warfare with Hamas ends up looking like total war. Of course total war is bad. But calling out for it to stop doesn't work if the 'peace' is a greater threat. And no-one has a solution to that.

[–] [email protected] 1 points 23 hours ago

Lemmy’s dominant view amounts to Israel evil.

make peace

Talking about peace has become more rare. Calls for the destruction of Israel are leading the pack.

The whole I/P situation is complex, terrible, polarized, heavily propagandized, and on a bad trajectory.

Actually trying to understand the situation and listening to all voices is difficult. It’s much easier to westsplain the situation with „colonizer“, „justice“, „racism“, and „oppression“. This serves really well to paint oneself in the most morally virtuous light.

Just a little bit of nuance would be helpful.