this post was submitted on 13 Jan 2025
226 points (98.3% liked)

movies

2020 readers
211 users here now

Matrix room: https://matrix.to/#/#fediversefilms:matrix.org

Warning: If the community is empty, make sure you have "English" selected in your languages in your account settings.

🔎 Find discussion threads

A community focused on discussions on movies. Besides usual movie news, the following threads are welcome

Related communities:

Show communities:

Discussion communities:

RULES

Spoilers are strictly forbidden in post titles.

Posts soliciting spoilers (endings, plot elements, twists, etc.) should contain [spoilers] in their title. Comments in these posts do not need to be hidden in spoiler MarkDown if they pertain to the title’s subject matter.

Otherwise, spoilers but must be contained in MarkDown.

2024 discussion threads

founded 2 years ago
MODERATORS
 

An animator has sued Disney for allegedly copying the idea for hit franchise Moana from his decades-old screenplay without his consent.

Buck Woodall filed a suit in a California federal court on Friday claiming that Disney lifted many elements of a screenplay he had written for an animated film titled Bucky.

...

Woodall initially sued Disney last year but a California court ruled in November that his filing had come too late and dismissed it. The release of Moana 2 allowed the animator to sue the production giant anew, on the same basis.

The suit alleges a “fraudulent enterprise that encompassed the theft, misappropriation and extensive exploitation of Woodall’s copyrighted materials” on part of former Mandeville Films development director Jenny Marchick, now head of development at DreamWorks Animation.

The suit states that Woodall gave Marchick a screenplay and trailer for Bucky in 2003 and was then asked for more materials over the next few years, including character designs, production plans, budgets, and storyboards. Woodall claims he delivered “extremely large quantities of intellectual property and trade secrets” for projects titled Bucky and Bucky the Wave Warrior and was told by Marchick she would get the film greenlit.

“Disney’s Moana was produced in the wake of Woodall’s delivery to the defendants of virtually all constituent parts necessary for its development and production after more than 17 years of inspiration and work on his animated film project,” the suit states.

It also points out alleged overlaps between Bucky and Moana 2.

Both are set in an ancient Polynesian village and follow teenagers who set out on a dangerous voyage to save their land, and meet ancient spirits who manifest as animals on their journey.

The suit specifically points out details like the rooster and pig companions, a meeting with the Kakamora warrior tribe, a whirlpool that leads to a portal as all being lifted from the screenplay of Bucky.

you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
[–] NineMileTower 25 points 1 day ago* (last edited 1 day ago) (3 children)

I want to see his trailer and screenplay from 2003.

From another article:

This is not the first time Woodall has taken legal action against Disney. A previous lawsuit regarding the first Moana film was dismissed in November last year due to the statute of limitations. However, the release of the sequel has allowed Woodall to file a new complaint.

If he had evidence of his creation being stolen, why did he wait so long? This all just seems like a cash grab or something to me. Also, $10 billion? That's a good way to be dismissed as a fraudster.

Disney made it's empire from stealing from the public domain. They don't need to steal from anyone. And if they did, he probably agreed to giving it to them through a terms and conditions acknowledgment at the Disneyland Theme park in 1997 that vindicates Disney from any legal repercussions.

[–] Feathercrown 5 points 17 hours ago (1 children)

stealing from the public domain

There is no such thing

[–] NineMileTower 3 points 16 hours ago (1 children)

Ok, sorry. They didn't steal. They used public domain stories to make billions of dollars and used it to fight tooth and nail for their characters to not enter public domain and lengthen copyright laws for years and years.

[–] Feathercrown 1 points 16 hours ago* (last edited 16 hours ago)
[–] [email protected] 18 points 1 day ago* (last edited 1 day ago) (3 children)

Attorneys don't just file a suit because their client said so: they generally need to be shown there's an actionable case with a chance if winning, and in this case it probably took a lot of time and information gathering to get to that point. Also, it's Disney, which probably makes most attorneys extra cautious.

[–] [email protected] 14 points 1 day ago (1 children)

Attorneys don’t just file a suit because their client said so: they generally need to be shown there’s an actionable case with a chance if winning

Man, I used to believe that.

The last 8 years have shown me otherwise.

[–] [email protected] 9 points 1 day ago

Sorry, I should have specified good attorneys, not assclowns who are working double time to get disbarred and censured. 🤣

[–] [email protected] 5 points 1 day ago (1 children)

Is 8 years a reasonable time for that? I'm genuinely asking. Assuming he had no reason to act before the first movie, as a layman, that seems like a long time to prepare for.

[–] [email protected] 4 points 1 day ago

IANAL, I just read legal blogs from time to time, so take this as a simple blanket explanation. Without details of the case it's hard to say. IP law gets insanely complex. It's also very likely that this animator was told the case was not actionable by an attorney some years ago, but then talked to a someone else with a different legal opinion more recently. Then there's the cost of litigation, which will be extreme given this is Disney, so it probably took time to get the money together for a retainer, and financial risk of a loss and counter-suit makes it risky.

[–] NineMileTower 3 points 1 day ago

That's a good point too.

[–] [email protected] 18 points 1 day ago (1 children)

Maybe he didn't have the money to launch a suit.

[–] NineMileTower 7 points 1 day ago (1 children)