this post was submitted on 14 Oct 2024
37 points (95.1% liked)

Marvel Studios

3122 readers
18 users here now

Lemmy

Welcome to MarvelStudios, a community for discussing all things related to Marvel TV/Film productions with a focus on Marvel Studios.

This community is a place to discuss, share and generally have fun with all things Marvel Studios.

Upcoming TV/Film:

MCU TV/Film Discussion:

Non-MCU Discussion:

Misc Discussion:

Community Guidelines

  1. Be constructive. As a community this is place for discussion, things you liked, things you didn't like, any everything in between. Low effort comments don't add to the discussion.
  2. Be civil. Disagreements happen. Don't attack others. Take a moment and reconsider before you post an inflammatory comment in all caps.
  3. No spam. Please don't post spam, trolling or other low effort content. If you're a human and you saw something interesting or had an interesting thought, you're probably fine.
  4. Memes are allowed. We're a small community, feel free to post memes or similar content. Funny things are good. If it becomes a problem we can discuss changing the rules.

In addition like any community we follow the Lemmy.World content policy rules. In short, don't attack people or groups.

Spoiler Guidelines

When should something no longer be considered a spoiler? In general use your best judgement. If want something more specific,

Related Communities:

founded 2 years ago
MODERATORS
MimicJar
JarvisBot
37
"Doctor Strange 3" is reportedly in development, according to Production Weekly. Denzel Washington is rumored to play Dormammu. (lemmy.ml)
submitted 3 months ago by [email protected] to c/marvelstudios
14 comments fedilink hide all child comments
 
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
[–] MimicJar 8 points 3 months ago (1 children)

But who is the "everyone" that hated it? Where are they? By what metric?

Let's discuss it for a moment,

I would say Thor was an OK film, definitely a lower point in the MCU (at the time). I would say Thor 2 was about the same, maybe a bit worse since it continued the boring trend of Thor. Thor 3 was a breath of fresh air, making me actually care about the character. Thor 4 was definitely a step down. It had fun moments, but wasted opportunity.

Now let's look at critic v audience for all Thor films,

  • Thor - 77% v 76%
  • Thor: The Dark World - 67% v 75%
  • Thor: Ragnarok - 93% v 87%
  • Thor: Love and Thunder - 63% v 76%

That all roughly tracks with what I said. Maybe the audience was too lenient. Maybe the critics were too harsh. Rotten Tomatoes is just one source, we can look at more, but I think they're roughly correct.

Also, just for calibration sake, let's look at Secret Invasion - 52% v 44%.

[–] Omegamanthethird 4 points 3 months ago (3 children)

Part of my point was that Thor 4 was successful by the metrics. But in reality it was hated, to the point where I think it damaged both Taika Waititi's reputation and the Thor brand.

However, you can look at the box office for some more insight. Because while it did well because of the hype, it's success was short lived.

Domestic box office total Thor 1-4; DS2

$181M $206M $315M $343M $411M

2nd Weekend Drop Thor 1-4; DS2

47.2% 57.3% 53.5% 67.7% 67.0%

I added Doctor Strange 2 as well for reference. I think Thor 4 mostly benefited from Thor 3's success in the same way Thor 2 benefited from Loki in the Avengers. And both fell off faster after the initial weekend than their predecessors because word of mouth sucked.

Thor 5 would not do as well, and could quite possibly bomb.

[–] [email protected] 4 points 3 months ago

in reality

Reality is subjective. Lots of people will watch a movie and simply not engage in a public discourse about it.

[–] MimicJar 3 points 3 months ago

I mean Avengers: Endgame also had a 58.7% drop off on the second weekend, that makes it look similar to Thor 2.

I don't disagree that there are multiple ways to measure this. This is basically the jobs of multiple people in the film industry.

And of course we're just talking Domestic, what if a film is more successful internationally? What if it bombs internationally, but is amazing domestically?

Also DS2 and Thor 4 both came out after Endgame, is superhero fatigue real, how do we measure it. Also after the peak of COVID, some reports say theaters still aren't back to pre-pandemic attendance.

I don't say all this to discourage discussion. I just think that we (and anyone) can probably use numbers to prove anything.

I definitely agree that as a viewer, Thor 4 was a step down. But I don't think it turned me off of a Thor 5. In fact after Thor 1 & 2 I had low expectations for 3, I would have said cancel/scrap it and give me something else, but it turned out to be the best one.

I have my criticisms of DS2, but I'm excited for DS3.

[–] Squizzy 3 points 3 months ago

Definitely sick of Taika's shtick these days. Jojo rabbit was good but Thor was aggressively shit and the fact he offered Natalie Portman a role in his star wars movie not realising she was already in a trilogy was a cherry on top for him not really focusing on what he is doing and just importing his same comedy into everything.