I'm fairly certain that's not true. If you subscribe to something, you won't get comments or upvotes, but you'll typically get posts. I can see that I'm literally the only subscriber on this instance to many communities, and I can see all the previous posts.
Moreover, for many of my subscriptions it's the other way around. I subscribed to everything on 2023-08-04 (i.e. the 4th of August) - I can usually see the posts up to that point, but nothing after.
Some examples of Communities I've subscribed to that have new posts at their instance but not this one:
[email protected]
[email protected]
[email protected]
[email protected] (this is the only one where there's no posts, past or present)
[email protected]
I'm seeing now though all those Communities have their subscription set to 'Pending', so maybe that's the issue. But I don't know how to move it past that point (I don't think it ever changes by itself).
Hmmm, now I'm noticing that Communick brings in posts from [email protected] when the other instance doesn't, so maybe it's just a fediverse thing.
The image is from my Subscribed feed for this instance and another one (same subs on both).
I've also noticed things like https://feddit.nl/c/trendingcommunities having 26 posts, but https://communick.news/c/[email protected] having zero, and https://lemmings.world/c/wwdits having newer posts than communick.news' version of it.
I don't know what happens behind the scenes, so maybe there's just some catching up to do, but was wondering if anything more fundamental was going on.
Thanks.
If I get it correctly, is like fakehistoryporn but for movies, right?
I think so, yeah. My own posts there vary widely in popularity (to phrase it euphemistically), so I'm maybe not the right person to ask though.
I wish you well. Personally, I'm a bit gloomy about the prospect of growing communities.
To share some data from [email protected]:
2023-07-19 521 subs 05 posts
2023-07-20 533 subs 13 posts
2023-07-21 633 subs 18 posts
2023-07-22 677 subs 19 posts
2023-07-23 710 subs 20 posts
2023-07-24 740 subs 21 posts
2023-07-25 753 subs 22 posts
2023-07-26 760 subs 23 posts
2023-07-27 781 subs 24 posts
2023-07-28 785 subs 24 posts
2023-07-29 794 subs 24 posts
2023-07-30 794 subs 24 posts
2023-07-31 798 subs 24 posts
2023-08-01 802 subs 24 posts
2023-08-02 807 subs 24 posts
2023-08-03 807 subs 24 posts
2023-08-04 826 subs 24 posts
2023-08-05 846 subs 24 posts
I was involved in an attempt to grow this community.
Two or three of us posted on the 20th July and 21st July, and you can see the subs jump from 533 to 677.
I kept posting 1 post a day until the 27th, but found that, the more I posted what I thought was amusing the more you actually had to be me to agree. If anyone ever commented on a post they didn't get or thought unfunny, there's maybe something I could do about it.
From then, subs have grown (I assume the recent jumps are due to Sync users), but posts and comments have not.
So it's not just about getting more subscribers - it has to be the right kind of subscribers.
Lemmy Kings sitting on porcelein thrones, dis-interestedly calling out for "More content! No! Not that kind! Get me some more Content Creators from the village!" are of no value.
If you're increasing subscribers, but it's still just you posting into the void, it's hard not to get disillusioned.
I've never seen it, but in that poster, Seth is one of the few actors who looks like he's got his head on correctly. Greenie on the left looks like her head might actually fall off. (I'd probably watch it if that was one of the plots)
