Not everyone uses or has an unlimited internet connection. So when someone posts a link to a page that contains autoplay video, it fucks us over by surprise by sucking our internet credit dry. It is impossible to disable autoplay in either of the two browsers (Chrome & Firefox). Google has been trying for over 10 years to make a disable mechanism for autoplay and so far they cannot handle the job.
I got burnt by this thread, which is not slrplnk.net but it’s an example of a discriminatory nuisance that harms poor people (who likely have bandwidth quotas). It’s also eco-harmful to waste network energy.
Animated GIFs are a similar but complicated problem and should be treated the same. Blocking images does not block animated GIFs, and while it’s possible to automatically stop an animated GIF, it only stops the playing not the fetching.
When I suggest banning “uncautioned” autoplay, I mean to say there is no issue as long as the existence of autoplay is made loud and clear by the author, so thread visitors cannot get burnt by a surprise hit-and-run bandwidth theft.
Thanks for the tip. I’m using a 16-year old PC that runs Debian. It has lived the lives of ~8 smartphones so far and produced no e-waste. I have a ~9-yr old Android for just some niche purposes but I would not consider using that tiny screen as a browser.
Your tip might be useful in some situations where someone tags an article as autoplay and I am high motivated to read it. But then I would first try lynx before resorting to a phone.
Ah, I see. In that case you probably already know about the about:config setting as well if you're using Firefox (or a fork). But here's a link for anyone else curious on desktop.
It’s interesting how there are various CSS hacks and short-lived plugins for stopping autoplay and animated GIFs in Firefox, and Google has been stumped on this for 15 years with Chromium -- yet Mozilla (who gets 83% of its funding from Google) has this simple switch that supposedly just works. I will certainly be running these settings. It will be interesting to see if it fails in any cases.
Though it’s worth noting that Chromium users are still stuffed. And animated GIFs are probably unaffected by these settings in FF.