Gotta be honest, watching the titles of the posts getting deleted made me a bit nostalgic, because it was an almost 5yo account.
However, now that's old news, and my account is totally gone.
I won't miss it really, I like Lemmy a lot more.
this post was submitted on 08 Aug 2023
562 points (96.2% liked)
13435 readers
1 users here now
founded 4 years ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
Consider removing it so users won't find it... Because the less value they get from reddit, the more likely it is they will come here instead.
Or that they just can't solve a problem. I'm all for fucking over reddit, but individual users get hit way harder than reddit when you delete posts containing technical info.
There needs to be a script, that moves each of your reddit comment over to Lemmy and edits the reddit comment with a link to the lemmy post
I like this compromise.
I have already seen bots that are moving complete reddit subs to their respective communities. It's really annoying, because there's no actual engagement whatsoever
It’s a compromise; the discussions aren’t lost, Reddit doesn’t get to have the data anymore, but like you said, there’s no engagement. The engagement needs to occur over here with new topics, possibly linking back to the copied old ones.
I agree, reddit gets most of their traffic from the engagement surrounding the latest shitposts and low-effort memes. (Or just genuine community content if you prefer)
Months old posts are hardly relevant to large scale user engagement and it's unlikely that the one user trying to solve a problem by visiting a years old thread is going to have much of an impact.
If people are going to move away from the site in a healthy manner, they need to realise for themselves that it's time to move on. Better to have a bunch of hopeful and curious people looking for new opportunities rather than bitter and resentful users which are going to vent their frustration elsewhere.
Finally some sane voice. People don't seem to think 2cm in front of their nose.
But I wanna fuck over my reddit IPO >:(
And if the user deletes it, at least archive it beforehand on archive.org.
Yeah and then they get unhappy with reddit and find Lemmy. :)
And Lemmy will probably not have the answer they're looking for. As someone who has seen the answer to my problems most likely be in deleted comments before, fucking don't. It doesn't make anyone more likely to look at Lemmy, it just makes their lives harder in an already unbearably stressful world.
If you want to purge your memes and witty comments, go for it. Just leave the valuable technical information FOR THE LOVE OF GOD.
It won't if people remain on reddit. :)
But for individuals, it either does or it doesn't. It doesn't matter if someone in a few years happens to ask the same question and get an answer on Lemmy.
I tried a few times already searching for somewith with lemmy like
[technical issue] lemmyor
[technical issue] [instance]Guess how many results came up from that...The SEO right now is shit for those instances and discoverability. Searching for reddit will currently will not even mention something to lemmy or similiar.
Which query did you run?
A huge number of people who read reddit posts aren't actually reddit users. Reddit has become just as important a repository of internet knowledge as Stack Overflow or Wikipedia. If you're having trouble with software or something technical, the information on Reddit is invaluable.
That information does not exist on Lemmy Lemmy as an alternative when it comes to that information that already exists in the world is not a viable alternative.
The best possible thing that people moving to Lemmy can do is leave their comment and post history up, but continue to provide good answers to questions here on Lemmy. Eventually the knowledge on Reddit will be here or outdated enough to fade into obscurity.
I was active in sysadmin subs. My people need those comments
Yeah I was in the Home Assistant sub. The number of times I Googled something I was struggling with, only to find a Reddit thread with MY comment telling people how to solve the exact issue I'm struggling with lol, I'll leave it up.
Haha... As if my content on Reddit has any value to anyone.
You'd be surprised sometimes.
They won't come here... They'll go wherever they can to solve the problem, which won't be here because Lemmy doesn't really show up in search results yet
Depends on the search engine I think? I was getting lots of nice results on "Lemmy neovim" on Kagi.
But yeah, fully aware that almost all people use Google and that the current results may not be as good as reddit.
In my experience with google at least, you have to specifically add "lemmy" to get any results to show up (and a lot of them aren't related to the search term, just general lemmy pages), which doesn't solve the problem until enough people know to add it.
I'm all for lemmy overtaking reddit but let's not waste people's time by deleting useful information 🙃. Deleting comments with solutions to problems will just come off as obnoxious and make people want to avoid lemmy.