bitflag

joined 2 years ago
MODERATOR OF
[–] bitflag 1 points 3 months ago

En termes plus clairs : un français de 1945 reçoit une pension totale équivalente de ce qu'il a cotisé placé à un taux annuel de 2%. S'il avait placé cet argent lui même avec un rendement net de 3%, il aurait été gagnant. Pour un français de 2000, il sera gagnant en plaçant au delà de 0,3%... sachant que la bourse fait autour de 7% brut.

Si les français comprenaient ce graphique, ils demanderaient immédiatement la retraite par capitalisation.

[–] bitflag 1 points 4 months ago* (last edited 4 months ago) (1 children)

Macron is hell-bent on dismantling public service

This is a complete myth: France public spending has never been this high (yes, even adjusted for inflation). France has never had so many public employees. France's health care spending has grown (fast) every year. Taxes have not significantly been dropped either.

Macron's government has also passed many left-oriented bills: 1 € meals for poor student, free contraceptive and morning after pills, culture check for youth, increased paternity leave, alleviating the SNCF debt, coverage of listening and dental prosthesis, subsidies for increasing housing insulation or repairing clothes, higher taxation on polluting cars, the shutdown of the airport project in Nantes, surrogate mothers, etc. You are telling me none of this could be worked on further with the left?

People voting for the retirement age to be 60 will never agree with people saying it should be 70.

For one nobody is saying it should be 70, for two the 60 year age is being quietly dropped by the left. Everyone knows we ain't going back to the 1981 age, given the demography.

But the centre and left can recognize there's an obvious demographic and financial issue. And surely can find a compromise where people with long career and hard labor retire early, and those with office jobs and long studies can probably retire a bit later. In other countries like Germany, alliances ranging from far left to centre right can work on compromises and agree on a single program. It's perfectly doable to find middle ground.

but you fail to realize how this confirms how bigoted

I think you fail to realize that in 1982, perspectives on LGBT issues were FAR FAR different than they are today. Huguette Bello, a communist which was proposed as a prime minister by the left, refused to support gay marriage, and that was in 2013 not 1982. But she is not a bigot and Barnier is?

[–] bitflag 1 points 4 months ago

Not much no. The far right strategy for the past few years has been to be quiet and appear moderate and dignified, so as to shed their image of fascist extremists. (and yes, that seems to work)

[–] bitflag 1 points 4 months ago* (last edited 4 months ago) (3 children)

Any compromise with Macron is unfortunately impossible. There is no way a single measure of the NFP would have gotten adopted if they had bent the knee

Of course there are. There's plenty of ideological overlap on public services, LGBT rights, the environment.

And, sure, the far right should never be an ally, but if the idiots are going to follow you, why tell them to fuck off?

Because when the situation was reversed and the far right voted along with Macron's party, the left cried about a supposed "alliance with the fascists".

voted against the decriminalization of homosexuality

This is outright misinformation. He voted against lowering the age of consent for gay sex with minors from 18 to 15 yo. And that was more than 40 years ago too. Homosexuality is legal in France since basically the French revolution back in the 18th century.

You’re so full of shit it’s not even funny.

Says the guy broadcasting fake news.

And, sure, the far right should never be an ally, but if the idiots are going to follow you, why tell them to fuck off?

[–] bitflag 1 points 4 months ago (4 children)

In a time when avoiding a far right government should be his first concern, I strangely mostly read about him shooting against the left

That's because the left has also been shooting mostly against his government as well, while ignoring the far right.

[–] bitflag 3 points 4 months ago

Macron can't run for another term so he doesn't really care about his future electoral chances.

[–] bitflag 0 points 4 months ago (11 children)

26,000 people in Paris. That's basically nothing, the NFP militants came out but there's no popular support for the protest beyond that.

For the left to call itself "the winner" was a mistake: not only do they control 1/3 of the parlement only, but by refusing all compromise and branding Macron's party "the enemy" they were guaranteed to never be able to gather more support for their bills. It's so bad that they were seriously discussing passing some bill on pension reform with the help of the far right.

[–] bitflag 1 points 4 months ago (1 children)

En tant que Français…

Ou Espagnol, Italien, Polonais... je te fais pas la liste exhaustive des 29 états.

Le marché sans intervention de l’État,

Mais qui parle de pas faire intervenir l'état ? Les libéraux c'est pas les libertariens

je te signal qu’on a déjà essayer en France et c’était pas joli-joli non plus : ça s’appelle le 19éme siècle

Le 19ème siècle n'était pas DU TOUT dépourvu de régulations, c'est pas parce que le code du travail était moins épais que y'avait aucune règles en matière économique ou commerciale, bien au contraire.

Ce qui est bien avec les libéraux c’est qu’ils ont vraiment la mémoire courte…

Alors que les socialistes ils font du révisionnisme historique ? C'est hôpital qui se fout de la charité.

[–] bitflag 1 points 4 months ago (3 children)

Pas du tout ! Schengen c'est la liberté d'installation permanente, en tant que français tu peux librement aller vivre et travailler partout dans la zone.

car le marché sera toujours "déranger” par les incidences du réel

Par opposition au dirigisme où tout est toujours parfait ? Le marché n'est pas parfait mais on a pas encore trouvé mieux (on a en revanche fait bien pire)

[–] bitflag 1 points 4 months ago (5 children)

C'est l'espace Schengen, oui, 29 pays où les gens circulent librement. Je connais pas de plus grande zone de libre circulation au monde.

[–] bitflag 1 points 4 months ago (7 children)

Non il n'y a aucun keynésien en France, ni vrai libéral. Il n'y a pas eu un seul budget en excédent depuis les années 70 donc nada côté keynésien.

je ne vois personne prôner l’ouverture des frontières pour favoriser la libre circulation des personnes et ainsi améliorer la flexibilité du marché

Il y a quand même un nombre significatif de soutiens au marché commun. La libre circulation de l'Irlande à la Roumanie c'est libéral

[–] bitflag 1 points 4 months ago (9 children)

On pas besoin de ressusciter Marx ou Keynes pour savoir que le programme de Macron n'est pas marxiste et que celui du NFP n'est pas keynésien.

view more: ‹ prev next ›