Asklemmy

I think people are worrying about it too much.

On Reddit, there were tons of duplicates. r/tumblr and r/CuratedTumblr. r/animemes and r/animememes and r/goodanimemes. r/gaming and r/games.

For Magic the Gathering there was r/magicTCG, r/mtg, r/magicthecirclejerking, r/MagicArena, r/EDH, r/mtgmemes, r/mtgfinance, r/ModernMagic, r/Pauper, r/mtgbrawl, r/DinosaursMTG, a bunch more, plus probably a dozen more I didn't even know about.

Dungeons & Dragons had r/DnD, r/dndnext, r/onednd, r/DungeonsandDragons, r/DnDMemes, r/3d6, and again, lots more.

If there are enough people in each community, great! More communities! If not, that's still okay! People will naturally gravitate towards more active communities. A lot of the duplicate communities will eventually figure themselves out and one will become the "main community." We just have to wait a bit. For now I'm just subscribing to anything that matches my interest to see what happens with it.

There is no “default” community. The community with the most engagement is the one that will survive.

I see it as a good thing - like you say, people can find the community that suits them, just as fans of a football side can join one (non-Reddit/Lemmy) forum or another (or both).

Likely one or two communities on any given topic will become the dominant ones over time, but for now I think it's good that there's a chance to kind of start over with communities following their own principles and ideas.

What might be good would be if communities of the same topic were to agree to crosslink to each other in their sidebars (much as the sfwporn network did on Reddit).

I think keeping them as separate communities with separate mods is a good thing though, it lets the subscribers decide if a community is what they want, without it being the only game in town.

It will, but I think at least in the short term it's a good thing. Lemmy.ml was hit hard yesterday, and despite that, I was still able to participate in discussion from many other servers.

I think over time, Lemmy will be improved to present these external communities a bit more cleanly. And when that happens, I hope that communities across different servers "mesh together" in such a way that they don't feel separate at all. And if any of those component servers ever have issues, the remaining servers that are online can continue to have discussions, rather than the entire community just grinding to a halt.

One possible case is people who are invested in this enough might build an instance dedicated to a community and people might gravitate towards that. Say, gaming@lemmygame. It is just names anyway.

That is indeed a problem that can happen, as I saw other people commenting about this issue.

I am somewhat optimistic that people will gravitate towards the bigger communities, making them the unofficial defaults. But there is the risk of people being split into lots of smaller ones, which may cause them to die due to low traction.

Big thing is to first search ALL communities (not just in local instance) before creating a new 'subreddit'. Some appear to be linked (like Tech groups) because when I posted I saw a note about it being cross-posted.

But certainly from Beehaw, I saw the various Lemmy communities listed, and I did a join from there (says subscription pending still). This would cut down on segmentation / fragmentation.