While I have hundreds of each fish hoarded, I didn't collect stats on them during the process. For this document, all stats were collected after June 10, 2023
All fish stats are gathered with Well-Fed bonus, and no fishing buddy
current sample size is 300 Catches, I'd like to get to 1000+ I will adjust this document as I gather more data
Well-fed critical hits seem to be around 3% (when you fish and it explodes a number of fish all around you)
Red Seaweed seems to spawn around 11%
Memories seem to spawn around 1.6% (need more samples to be sure)
You may get different odds due to quest progression and level and there might even be random seed differences between players.
| Drop | Location | Spot Color | Percent Chance | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Anglerfish | Forgotten Lands | Gold | 100% | |
| Bass | Forest of Valor | None | 50% | |
| Bass | Sunlit Plateau | White | 4% | |
| Bass | Peaceful Meadow | White | 10% | |
| Bass | Peaceful Meadow | None | 60% | |
| Bream | Peaceful Meadow | Blue | 83% | |
| Carp | Forest of Valor | Blue | 100% | |
| Carp | Sunlit Plateau | Blue | 85% | |
| Carp | Sunlit Plateau | White | 9% | |
| Catfish | Peaceful Meadow | Gold | 100% | |
| Cod | Dazzle Beach | None | 27% | |
| Cod | Glade of Trust | White | 17% | |
| Cod | Glade of Trust | None | 45% | |
| Cod | Forgotten Lands | None | 23% | |
| Crab | Frosted Heights | Blue | 16% | |
| Crab | Frosted Heights | White | 30% | |
| Fugu | Dazzle Beach | Red | 66% | (lightning+bait) |
| Green Seaweed | Forest of Valor | None | 50% | |
| Green Seaweed | Sunlit Plateau | None | 45% | |
| Green Seaweed | Peaceful Meadow | None | 40% | |
| Green Seaweed | Glade of Trust | None | 40% | |
| Green Seaweed | Dazzle Beach | None | 72% | |
| Green Seaweed | Forgotten Lands | None | 76% | |
| Green Seaweed | Frosted Heights | None | 100% | |
| Here and There Fish | All | All | 12% | 6A-10A and 6P-10P |
| Herring | Dazzle Beach | Blue | 33% | |
| Herring | Dazzle Beach | White | 100% | |
| Herring | Glade of Trust | Blue | 40% | |
| Herring | Glade of Trust | White | 17% | |
| Kingfish | Dazzle Beach | Blue | ?? | (night)(need more samples) |
| Lancetfish | Forgotten Lands | Blue | 42% | |
| Lobster | Glade of Trust | Gold | 100% | |
| Perch | Forest of Valor | White | 33% | |
| Perch | Sunlit Plateau | White | 33% | |
| Perch | Sunlit Plateau | Blue | 14% | |
| Perch | Sunlit Plateau | None | 54% | |
| Pike | Forest of Valor | Gold | 100% | |
| Rainbow Trout | Forest of Valor | White | 66% | |
| Rainbow Trout | Peaceful Meadow | Blue | 16% | |
| Rainbow Trout | Peaceful Meadow | White | 90% | |
| Salmon | Sunlit Plateau | White | 52% | |
| Salmon | Frosted Heights | Blue | 16% | |
| Shrimp | Dazzle Beach | Blue | 66% | |
| Sole | Forgotten Lands | Blue | 14% | |
| Sole | Forgotten Lands | White | 20% | |
| Squid | Glade of Trust | Blue | 60% | |
| Squid | Forgotten Lands | Blue | 42% | |
| Sturgeon | Frosted Heights | Gold | 100% | |
| Swordfish | Dazzle Beach | Gold | 100% | |
| Tilapia | Frosted Heights | Blue | 66% | |
| Tilapia | Sunlit Plateau | Blue | ?? | (need more samples) |
| Tuna | Glade of Trust | White | 64% | |
| Tuna | Forgotten Lands | White | 60% | |
| Walleye | Sunlit Plateau | Gold | 100% |