Introduction to the Debate
- The session begins with an introduction to the debate, likening the discussion to the renovation of a house that requires either a simple facelift or complete demolition and rebuilding.
- The speaker introduces two prominent figures, Martin Wolf and Yanis Varoufakis, highlighting their expertise and contributions to the discussion on democratic capitalism.
- Wolf is noted for his influential commentary in economics and his book titled "The Crisis of Democratic Capitalism," while Varoufakis is recognized for his role as Greece's former Minister of Finance and his upcoming book "Technofeudalism."
Martin Wolf on Democratic Capitalism
- Martin Wolf argues that despite the crises affecting democratic capitalism, it remains the best political and economic system available today.
- He emphasizes the historical context, noting that two centuries ago, democracies were virtually nonexistent, whereas now many countries incorporate significant democratic elements.
- Wolf asserts that the evolution of democratic systems has been a natural outcome of market forces and that a decentralized economy is essential for political stability and citizen empowerment.
- He highlights improvements in quality of life over the past two centuries, such as increased life expectancy and reduced infant mortality, as evidence of the system's success.
- Wolf expresses a desire to enhance the functioning of democratic capitalism rather than abandon it, suggesting that the current issues should lead to constructive reforms.
Yanis Varoufakis's Response
- Yanis Varoufakis acknowledges the common ground shared with Wolf, particularly their mutual belief in democracy and decentralized market systems.
- He argues that while liberal democratic capitalism has been effective, it is also fundamentally flawed and requires significant reforms to address its shortcomings.
- Varoufakis draws a historical parallel to the decline of feudalism, suggesting that capitalism may also be on the verge of transformation due to emerging socioeconomic forces.
- He introduces the concept of "Cloud Capital," describing it as a new form of capital that prioritizes behavioral modification through algorithms and technology, which he believes undermines traditional capitalist structures.
- Varoufakis expresses concern about the implications of algorithm-driven platforms like Amazon, arguing they create a new form of feudalism where power and profits are concentrated in the hands of a few.
The Role of Technology in Capitalism
- Both speakers discuss the significant role of technology in shaping modern capitalism, with Varoufakis emphasizing the transformative impact of algorithmic systems on consumer behavior.
- Wolf counters by acknowledging the potential of technology to enhance productivity and economic growth, stressing that it is crucial to adapt political and economic frameworks to these advancements.
- Varoufakis warns that the increasing dominance of tech companies could lead to a situation where traditional market dynamics are disrupted, resulting in a lack of genuine competition.
- Wolf argues that while there are valid concerns regarding tech monopolies, there remains the possibility of reform and regulation to ensure that the benefits of technology are widely distributed.
- The conversation highlights the tension between the benefits of technological advancement and the risks of concentration of power and wealth in the digital age.
The Future of Democratic Capitalism
- The discussion shifts to the potential future of democratic capitalism, with Wolf cautioning against the rise of autocratic systems that could threaten democratic institutions.
- He points to historical examples where democratically elected leaders have undermined democratic processes, leading to authoritarian regimes.
- Varoufakis agrees that the current global landscape presents challenges, particularly with the rise of authoritarian capitalism exemplified by China's model.
- Both speakers express concern over the implications of a world where democratic capitalism may be overshadowed by systems that prioritize state control and economic efficiency over individual freedoms.
- They conclude that the future of democratic capitalism will depend on the ability to adapt to changing economic realities while preserving democratic values and institutions.
Martin Wolf is widely admired as one of the most influential economic commentators in the world. While he sees the flaws in the capitalist system he believes it is worth saving. Yanis Varoufakis is a globally renowned economist and a bestselling author. He rejects economic orthodoxies and advocates for a progressive post-capitalist new order. On February 2023 Wolf and Varoufakis came to the Intelligence Squared stage at the Tabernacle in Notting Hill to discuss and debate their competing views for a better world.
As Wolf argues in his new book, The Crisis of Democratic Capitalism, for all its recent failings – slowing growth, increasing inequality, widespread popular disillusion – democratic capitalism remains the best system we know for what Wolf calls human flourishing. And while progressives such as Varoufakis claim that democracy would function better without capitalism, Wolf believes that the two are complementary systems that need each other if either is to thrive.
Varoufakis by contrast believes that capitalism isn’t working for ordinary people. Political power is wielded by wealthy elites and tech overlords. As he sets out in his latest book Another Now, there could be a different way: one without banks, billionaires, tech giants or stock markets. In his alternative vision employees all have equal shares in companies, everyone is guaranteed a basic income and housing is socialised.
Should we admit that capitalism has had its day and strive for something new? Or can capitalism be made to work in a way that grants us all our fundamental freedoms?
About: Intelligence Squared is the world's premier forum for debate. Here you'll find the best of our past events.