-1
Dr. Gilbert Doctorow: Russia & the Turmoil in Syria & Georgia [46:02 | DEC 10 24 | Dialogue Works]
(youtu.be)
Current Situation in Syria
- The discussion begins with the acknowledgment of turmoil in Syria following the departure of Assad, highlighting the complexity of the situation.
- Russia and Iran, previously seen as supporters of Assad, are now viewed by some as losers in the current geopolitical landscape.
- The speaker emphasizes the need for caution in interpreting the situation, given Syria's diverse ethnic and religious demographics and the multitude of competing local and international influences.
- The inadequacy of the 30,000-strong armed forces to maintain control over the vast territory of Syria, which has suffered from a decade of civil war, is noted.
- The speaker reflects on the historical context, mentioning that the U.S. has been involved in financing various factions within Syria, complicating the narrative surrounding the conflict.
Role of Russia and Iran
- The speaker argues that Russia's military presence in Syria since 2015 has been focused on mediation rather than direct combat, which has allowed them to maintain influence.
- Russia has facilitated local resolutions and provided some stability, earning a degree of appreciation from various Syrian factions.
- Despite the setbacks faced by Iranian proxies, the speaker asserts that Iran's military capabilities remain intact and that it continues to seek a mutual defense agreement with Russia.
Geopolitical Dynamics and U.S. Involvement
- The speaker critiques U.S. sanctions and military involvement, arguing that they have significantly weakened the Syrian economy and contributed to the Assad government's challenges.
- The narrative suggests that the U.S. has been a destabilizing force in the region, funding factions that oppose Assad while ignoring the complexities of the situation.
- The speaker expresses skepticism about the U.S.'s ability to act as an honest broker in the ongoing conflict, viewing it instead as a co-belligerent.
Turkey's Role and Future Relations
- The discussion touches on Turkey's fluctuating position, with the speaker suggesting that Turkey has historically played both sides in the Syrian conflict.
- Despite Turkey's actions, the speaker believes that Russia will continue to engage with Turkey due to its strategic importance in the region.
- The potential for further cooperation on energy projects, such as the nuclear power station and gas pipelines, is mentioned as a reason for maintaining relations with Turkey.
Implications for Regional Stability
- The speaker raises concerns about ongoing instability in Syria potentially leading to further waves of refugees into Europe, particularly if violence escalates.
- Current discussions in the EU about returning Syrian refugees are deemed unrealistic, given the continuing risks in Syria.
- The possibility of new immigration flows into Europe is highlighted, suggesting that the situation remains precarious.
Russian Media Perspective and Historical Context
- The speaker reflects on the Russian media's portrayal of the situation, emphasizing a historical context that shapes current perceptions.
- There is a discussion about the legacy of colonial borders in the region and how they contribute to ongoing conflicts, particularly among ethnic groups.
- The speaker warns against oversimplifying the situation in Syria by comparing it to other conflicts, such as Libya, noting that each has unique dynamics.
Future Outlook and Conclusion
- The conversation concludes with a cautious optimism regarding the role of Russia in stabilizing Syria, despite the complex challenges ahead.
- The speaker believes that while the situation remains fluid, Russia's established relationships and mediation efforts may provide a pathway to a more stable future.
- Ultimately, the discussion emphasizes the need for nuanced understanding of the geopolitical landscape in Syria and the broader region.
About: Dedicated to dialogue and peace!
At Dialogue works, we believe there’s nothing more unstoppable than when people come together.
This group’s mission is to create a global community of diverse individuals who will support, challenge, and inspire one another by providing a platform for Dialogue.
We encourage you to share your knowledge, ask questions, participate in discussions, and become an integral part of this little community. Together we can become a better community and provide our members with a much better experience.