4
submitted 1 month ago by kescusay to c/askpolitics

Both are legislative bodies, so I'm curious about how they structurally differ.

top 7 comments
sorted by: hot top controversial new old
[-] Lemming421 1 points 1 month ago

The Commons are a publicly elected body and the seats from it are used to calculate which party/coalition has enough of a majority to form the government.

The Lords are either appointed or hereditary. They can be members of the government (Lord Cameron is the Foreign Secretary, for example), but their seats don’t count towards party numbers.

[-] kescusay 1 points 1 month ago

How are votes for legislation counted? Do they get to put their fingers on the scales?

[-] Lemming421 2 points 1 month ago

I’m not 100% sure, actually. I know the Lords are still politically aligned, but while I assume that bills have to go through both houses, I’m not sure how that works in practice.

They don’t teach politics in primary or high school and I didn’t study it at university. The news mostly covers the Commons - it’s rare to hear about the Lords blocking a bill, but not unheard of.

[-] doublejay1999 1 points 1 month ago

The Lords are not elected , for starters. They are hereditary peers (aristocracy whose ancestors did favours for William the Conqueror). Or political appointments.

Funny huh ?

[-] kescusay 2 points 1 month ago

I'd heard something like that, but I didn't know it was actually hereditary! That's ridiculous. Is there a good reason to maintain such a system?

[-] doublejay1999 2 points 1 month ago

I guess it’s a very effective subversion of representative democracy. !

[-] Lemming421 1 points 1 month ago* (last edited 1 month ago)

We look at the American system where both houses are elected and how that has just turned politics into even more of a popularity contest.

On the one hand, the entire concept of a hereditary aristocracy is anti-democratic.

On the other, I think the theory is a hereditary position is supposed to be able to think further ahead and be less influenced by populism.

this post was submitted on 25 Mar 2024
4 points (100.0% liked)

Ask Politics

12 readers
7 users here now

Welcome to Ask Politics, the community for civics-minded questions!

THE RULES

Posts

This is a community for asking questions on political topics. Want to know what the details of a bill are? Want to know the nature of a political appointment? Want to know the repercussions of a Supreme Court decision? This is the place for it!

But it is not a community to ask loaded questions for the specific purpose of triggering an argument.

For that reason, all posts to this community must be formatted as a question, without smuggling in any assertions.

DO post questions like, "What are the repercussions of X Senate bill?"

DO NOT post "questions" like, "This Senate bill will eat my dog and punch my baby. Here's a question mark to make it into a question?"

Feel free to include links to things like the texts of bills or clarifying statements in the body of your post, but don't just post links. And this is not a community for political news. There are plenty of those already.

Formatting

To make it easier to search and filter the community, please tag your questions with the country code they're applicable to, e.g.: [US] / [UK] / [CA]. Yes, that means this community is intended to be international.

If the question applies to a specific jurisdiction, you can specify that as well, e.g.: [US][NY]

A well-formatted question could look like this: "[US] How is the Supreme Court likely to rule on X case?"

Comments

And that's basically it! Hopefully, this can become a fun and informative community.

founded 1 month ago
MODERATORS