this post was submitted on 12 Jan 2024
17 points (100.0% liked)

Buildapc

3843 readers
29 users here now

founded 2 years ago
MODERATORS
 

I have a gtx 1660 super which turns off in the middle of doing something. I don't get any output to my monitor and even restarting doesn't solve the problem. It is quite random and very frustrating to say the least. The only solution I have now is to wait for an hour or so and restart - I'll get display output if I'm lucky.

When the gpu stops, the motherboard debug led doesn't light up. The led lights up only when I restart the PC.

Is there any way to check if the issue lies with the motherboard or the gpu without using another graphics card ?

(I dont have integrated graphics either, because I have an i5 10400f)

My motherboard is - MSI B460 M Pro VDH wifi

EDIT: Got a 4 month used rx 6600 for ~ $120 and now this problem no longer happens. it's not a substantial upgrade from my 1660 Super but an upgrade nonetheless.

top 9 comments
sorted by: hot top controversial new old
[–] j4k3 6 points 11 months ago* (last edited 11 months ago) (2 children)

Why do you say you need to wait an hour?

I can't speak to what is common practice in pcbuilds but if time is a factor I expect the issue to be thermal, especially if it is working and then stops. Check everything that has to do with power and use any available method to check for hot components. Any experienced electronics hobbyist will usually just do touch tests on chips, electrolytic capacitors, and inductors if you have decent access to board level components. Most GPUs have all the stuff covered in nonsense cosmetics. You just need to touch something grounded so that you don't have a static charge potential before touching board stuff.

I'm not saying this is your issue or anything, but it is common for through hole components that experience a lot of heat cycles eventually developing solder joint issues especially if the original manually soldered joint was bad. I would look for any power wire connection issue first.

The first rule of troubleshooting is "thou shalt check circuit ground." If there is some kind of real delay, I would cause the issue, and then immediately probe between the card and motherboard ground to check that they are still connected. Then I would put a 10A rated multimeter in series with ground and check the current to the card before and during the fault. Don't go down this path until people experienced with more pcbuilds chime in, this is just general electronics 101 type info.

[–] [email protected] 5 points 11 months ago

I agree, sounds like a heat issue. I'd reseat the GPU, then run a thermal load test with something like FurMark, all while watching temps on something like HWInfo.

If it crashes when the temp spikes, suspect heat is triggering an emergency shutdown of the GPU. Thermal paste eventually wears out, and for a 1660, I'd imagine it's pretty crusty paste by now (if it hasn't been changed before).

[–] [email protected] 2 points 11 months ago (1 children)

Hi, thanks for commenting.

I don't know why I have to wait for an hour, even if I do not do anything to stress the GPU.

A week ago I was not even able to get to the bios screen because the display would stop getting any signal from my 1660 super.

I noticed that the frequency of that happening reduced once I took the card out and put it back in. Even so it would exhibit the same problem at random times.

I just got a 5 month old - barely used RX6600 for $120 the other day. So far I haven't seen the same issue occur with this card.

[–] j4k3 1 points 11 months ago

Could be thermal or electrical. Probably should redo the thermal paste. Make sure there is no corrosion on the card edge connector or in the motherboard connector's pin contacts. The latter is a subtle one too. If you see any contact discoloration it can be a poorly plated pin and can cause a bad connection as oxide does not conduct electrons. In hobby electronics and the cheap connectors I encounter, this happens a good bit and is super annoying because it is hard to spot and diagnose in many instances. Over the last 10 years the types of cheaply available connectors has grown in their sophistication and complexity. I would not be surprised if these same Chinese companies were now making motherboard connectors and parts. While it is nice to have cheap options, these cheap components are often at a bare bones type of production quality and process where some units will fail unlike the overbuilt and gold plated days of military spec components in the pre-90's era. Rusty connector pins can get scraped off enough to conduct for awhile after removing and reinserting. The effect may be different with different cards that scrape the pins in a slightly different way. However, just removing and reinserting the card causes the fiberglass to flex. The physical die and heatsink are anchored in different places and this tiny difference should move the heatsink compound ever so slightly, perhaps improving thermal contact. The same could be true of a dry solder joint where the flex causes better mechanical contact... or worse.

[–] [email protected] 3 points 11 months ago

With those symptoms (dying under load and takes an hour to turn back on) I would put it at a 90% chance this is a thermal issue with the video card. Have you made sure the GPU fans spin when under load? If they aren't spinning that's going to be your problem. If they are, how dirty is the heat sink and has that ever been cleaned? If you have pets and live in a place with carpet or a smoker you will get buildup in the heat sink that can kill airflow. With this card only being ~4 years old at most, I wouldn't expect the thermal paste to be an issue but it wouldn't hurt to replace it.

[–] [email protected] 2 points 11 months ago (1 children)

If I understand correctly, you’re getting a sudden loss of signal to the monitor but the rest of your system remains powered on (fans, lights, maybe capslock is also still responsive).

An abrupt full system shutdown is often the result of a thermal or power problem. If a component (CPU, GPU) overheats or the power supply is asked to deliver more power than it is able to, everything will cut out.

Others are citing thermal issues and there is merit in checking your temperatures but that is not likely to be the case here because of what I just listed. I would also add that an overheated GPU will be able to power on again within minutes, not an hour, after the shutdown event.

Symptoms point to a likely defective GPU. The most common point of failure is the VRAM. You can find and run Nvidia MATS/MODS diagnostic software to test the card’s memory and confirm whether or not that is what’s happening.

Ultimately, troubleshooting is a matter of isolating problems and the best way to isolate a hardware issue is by substituting in supplemental hardware.

If you’re able to replicate the issue fairly quickly (e.g by running a benchmark program to force the card to drop out), you might start with the power supply since it’s usually the cheaper component to replace.

[–] [email protected] 1 points 10 months ago (1 children)

I got a different GPU (an rx 6600) and it works fine. Never had the display blacking out problem even once.

If it's a problem with the VRAM, will my 1660 super be fixable ? I would like to give it to my younger sibling, if I can get it fixed.

[–] [email protected] 1 points 10 months ago

Yes, though whether or not it’s economical to do so will depend on local economics where you are.

If you bought the card new yourself, it likely would have come with at least a 3 year warranty.

[–] [email protected] 1 points 11 months ago* (last edited 11 months ago)

I've been having a similar issue recently with the same card, though it wasn't taking an hour to get the display back and the problem ended up being something wrong with Steam. It was not releasing things from video memory and would end up crashing steam, crashing games running, and disconnecting the display somehow once the VRAM got filled and tried to do more. All I had to do to get the display back was unplug the HDMI cable and plug it back in again.

I just wiped my Steam install and reinstalled it. Haven't had any issues since.