To introduce a little nuance, this is not always true in working dogs! What you want is to avoid in those cases are AKC (American Kennel Club) certified dogs; that's where it gets in-breedy—seriously, look up some of the requirements a dog has to meet in its breed to qualify. It's gross.

Anyhoo, in working dogs, a 'pedigree' is actually quite helpful because it shows that that dog comes from a long line of dogs who have been certified to do their job, and so your new farm pup is highly likely to be able to do it too. These breeds will usually have their own organization that oversees this; in border collies it's the ABCA (American Border Collie Association). This organization judges the dogs not on the specific dimensions of their bodies like the AKC, but on their ability to do the job a farmer needs them for.

Sorry for the ramble, I have two border collies and I think working dogs are super neat.

[–] Soggy 4 points 11 months ago (2 children)

Working dogs are great, but aren't usually great pets. They need a job, an outlet, and usually a lot of structure.

[–] [email protected] 1 points 11 months ago

Yep, grew up on a farm in Australia with kelpies. They're great dogs and really lovely.

However, I've seen them appearing in the city a bit and that's just a terrible idea all round. They need much more space and stimulation than they can get off a farm.

[–] [email protected] 1 points 11 months ago

They're challenging for sure and I don't recommend them to inexperienced/unprepared dog owners, but they can be amazing as pets! Very rewarding, especially once they get past the first year and a half or so. Then, if you've done well, you'll almost have your own language with these dogs and they'll understand almost everything you say to them. They're incredible. I may honestly never have a different breed of dog.

The huge 'BUT' is definitely everything you just said. They need outlets for their energy (even if it's just a hardcore game of fetch every day) and ways to engage their mind (Kong toys and smart balls do wonders for ours when it's raining) or they can be very anxious, destructive, and generally neurotic.