this post was submitted on 24 Oct 2023
58 points (98.3% liked)

LEGO

3706 readers
58 users here now

Show off your Lego, discuss your MOC's and builds, and talk news and upcoming sets here!

Rules

1 No bigotry - including racism, sexism, ableism, homophobia, transphobia, or xenophobia.

2 Be respectful, especially when disagreeing. Everyone should feel welcome here.

3 No porn.

4 No Ads / Spamming.

founded 1 year ago
MODERATORS
 

so, what are y'all working on? a few months back, I decided to build 6085, the Black Monarch's Castle. I always loved that set, but didn't have it when I was a kid, so I built it with the parts I have. then I modified it with some more modern touches, like the cheese wedge crenellation (yeah, that's not very modern, it's all relative). then I decided to expand. then expand more and more, to the point where it is now, with a very similar size and shape to the Ninjago city gardens.

staircases!

elaborate brick work!

modularity!

you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
[–] [email protected] 2 points 11 months ago

The ElDorado Fortress is one of the "BUT" sets. As in "this feature is good, but...", so it is a mixed experience.

The very idea to revive an iconic set of the Pirate era is laudable. To build it with a built base instead of a raised baseplate is good, BUT it costs a load of bricks and thus drives the price of the set up in a region where it should not be: beyond €200. A price of €199 would have been acceptable.

What contributed to the high brick count was that the whole set was designed in a modular fashion, which is basically a good idea, BUT the design fell short here and it is only partly modular, i.e. the pieces only fit in a limited number of combination - the modularity is far from universal.

And so, the boat is a BUT thing, too. It is nice that they included a little sailing boat, BUT it is totally unrealistic in it's design. The transom and rudder configuration is that of a motor boat, and the rigging is totally off with a square sail and a gaff sail on the same mast. This is as if they would sell car models with legs instead of wheels. OK, we can now discuss at length the amount of realism in a LEGO model, but this is so far off, it hurts.

The crane is a good idea and well-designed, BUT it lacks the reach to actually load and unload something from the boat.

The list goes on and on.

In the end, I decided to completely redo the model as a (large) MOC, non-modular this time. The island fortress will cover about 12 baseplates, and another 12 will be surrounding quays and docks. Luckily, I already have the polulation (20-30 blue-shirt soldiers and about 150-200 sailors - originally pirates, but they can be used as harmless laypersons, too) and about 50 guns. All collected for an abandoned project years ago.

Maybe I'll document my work on the boat, maybe I'll only provide it as a finished work. Don't know.