Never watched the anime or read the manga, but have knowledge from general cultural osmosis. I've been enjoying it. It's not great, but also much less awful then some other live action adaptations I've seen. Pretty solidly in B movie territory. Luffy's actor has the right energy, , though his accent is a little annoying sometimes. Crew members have been fun. Zoro's three swords look stupid, but they're doing their best. Like the couple nods to lack of direction. Nami is alright. Usopp and Sanji are a delight. Fights are a weird mix between trying to be as cool as the anime, and the reality that humans are not that graceful. Enjoyable, but also silly. Something I can watch and enjoy on my own, but probably won't introduce to my family.