this post was submitted on 23 Dec 2024
146 points (98.0% liked)
Overseas News
510 readers
109 users here now
A place for Australians and friends to share news from the other countries. Like all communities here, we discuss topics from the Australian perspective.
If you're looking for a global /c/worldnews instead, search for the many options on federated instances.
Rules
- Follow the aussie.zone rules
- We are not a generic World News clone. News must be relevant to Australians and our region. Obvious disregard will earn an warning and then a ban if continued. (If an article isn't from an Oceanian news outlet, and it doesn’t mention Australia, then it’s probably off-topic)
- Leave seppocentrism at the door. If you don't know what that means, you're not ready to post here yet.
- Avoid editorialising headlines. Opinions go in the comments, not the post.
founded 2 years ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
Interesting. Sorry its been so long with a reply, that time of year.
Had to go to the wiki article on Ivan Illich to see what he was all about. Certainly interesting ideas, although the wiki doesn't go into depth so i can't say whether i'd gel with them or not.
The one thing i'd say is he seems a little hard on institutions. Unfortunately the only reason we've made such advances to be able to have conversations about modes of education or over medicalisation is because of the boring, unseen and largely forgotten works of millions of individuals tied into an institutional framework of one sort or another.
For example, institutions like the British East India company did terrible, (fucked up) things; but also made connections, both social and mechanical. Through the company's actions many trade routes or ties we still use today. (Picked this one because of its controversial nature).
But as i write all this i'm well aware i might be overstating what i believe Ivan Illich' problems with institutions to be, so i should leave it there.
But the main point,
"Something is good, when it is uniquely and incomparably appropriate in its given setting."
I'd say the above quote about your response, thank you. You answered my question searching for a more universally applicable statement very well.