this post was submitted on 28 Jul 2024
472 points (94.9% liked)

Cool Guides

4729 readers
1 users here now

Rules for Posting Guides on Our Community

1. Defining a Guide Guides are comprehensive reference materials, how-tos, or comparison tables. A guide must be well-organized both in content and layout. Information should be easily accessible without unnecessary navigation. Guides can include flowcharts, step-by-step instructions, or visual references that compare different elements side by side.

2. Infographic Guidelines Infographics are permitted if they are educational and informative. They should aim to convey complex information visually and clearly. However, infographics that primarily serve as visual essays without structured guidance will be subject to removal.

3. Grey Area Moderators may use discretion when deciding to remove posts. If in doubt, message us or use downvotes for content you find inappropriate.

4. Source Attribution If you know the original source of a guide, share it in the comments to credit the creators.

5. Diverse Content To keep our community engaging, avoid saturating the feed with similar topics. Excessive posts on a single topic may be moderated to maintain diversity.

6. Verify in Comments Always check the comments for additional insights or corrections. Moderators rely on community expertise for accuracy.

Community Guidelines

By following these rules, we can maintain a diverse and informative community. If you have any questions or concerns, feel free to reach out to the moderators. Thank you for contributing responsibly!

founded 2 years ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
[–] exanime 6 points 4 months ago (1 children)

There are many good arguments against God. This is not one of them.

That is because this isn't an argument against god. It is simply a question that resulted in a Paradox about the character of god as described by the Church

Can 0 equal 1? The answer to that question isn’t yes/no, it’s that the question is invalid.

What? the question is not invalid. it is a yes/no, the *implications" of that yes or no however can carry significant correlations

Freewill does not equal non-freewill.

yeah, nobody is making this crazy claim...

[–] pachrist 1 points 4 months ago (1 children)

Yeah, probably would have been better to use dividing by 0 instead of 0=1 as the example, but the point still stands.

Yes/no isn't a valid answer to a paradox. Can God create a universe where there is freewill and there isn't freewill? Can God create a rock so large he can't lift it? Can he shit so big he can't flush it? All interesting, but in the end invalid questions. But shoehorning in a yes/no when the real answer is just undefined is incorrect.

It's good fun for an internet comment section, or irritating some youth group leader, but in the end not a useful question.

[–] exanime 3 points 4 months ago

I don't get why you say they are not valid questions? I see nothing invalid in them. Instead it seems to me you seem to disagree with the consequences such "yes/no" answers carry and are preemptively dismissing them

Overall this paradox is a thought experiment, as such, even in the absence of a concrete answer, it is still a very valid and valuable question