- Abadon
- Adam Cole
- Adam Page
- Andrade El Idolo
- Anna Jay
- Aubrey Edwards
- Brian Cage
- Britt Baker
- Mr. Brodie Lee
- Bryan Danielson
- Chris Jericho
- Christian Cage
- Chuck Taylor
- CM Punk
- Cody Rhodes
- Darby Allin
- Dustin Rhodes
- Eddie Kingston
- Hikaru Shida
- Jade Cargill
- Jeff Hardy
- John Silver
- Jon Moxley
- Jungle Boy
- Kenny Omega
- Kris Statlander
- Lance Archer
- Luchasaurus
- Malakai Black
- Matt Jackson
- Miro
- MJF
- Nick Jackson
- Nyla Rose
- Orange Cassidy
- Owen Hart
- Pac
- Paul Wight
- Penta El Zero M
- Powerhouse Hobbs
- Rey Fenix
- Ricky Starks
- Riho
- Ruby Soho
- Sammy Guevara
- Scorpio Sky
- Sting
- Tay Melo
- Thunder Rosa
- Trent Beretta
- Wardlow
- Yuka Sakazaki
Pre-order bonus: Matt Hardy and Broken Matt Hardy
Announced DLC (included with Elite Edition):
- Cash Wheeler
- Dax Harwood
- Keith Lee
- The Bunny
- HOOK
- Danhausen
