The post was mostly aimed at [email protected], but hearing what the community wants might help them to decide as well.
My vote would be for a broader definition.
- Less headaches for mods, since they wouldn’t have to worry about users who unknowingly post non-genre music. Also, it isn’t always easy to know if a song belongs in the genre.
- Users wouldn’t have to worry about whether a song they have in mind fits, making participating easier and less stressful.
- I think it would appeal to more people, since (I assume) most people would visit the community having a broad/descriptive definition in mind, leading to more community growth.
- There’s far more music that can be shared, leading to more diversity in the posted music.