this post was submitted on 04 May 2024
-14 points (33.3% liked)

Artificial Intelligence

1351 readers
22 users here now

Welcome to the AI Community!

Let's explore AI passionately, foster innovation, and learn together. Follow these guidelines for a vibrant and respectful community:

You can access the AI Wiki at the following link: AI Wiki

Let's create a thriving AI community together!

founded 1 year ago
-14
Generative AI is Not Theft (youtu.be)
submitted 6 months ago by markendsley to c/ai_
24 comments fedilink hide all child comments
 

I created this video after being spammed by artist groups claiming that Generative AI uses copied samples to create work.

you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
[–] [email protected] 1 points 6 months ago* (last edited 6 months ago)

I see your point. But it's not based on anything. You just claim AI creativity works like human cretivity without backing that up. While I too think this is the case... The interesting question would be: Is that really the case? And why? Without an explanation and reasoning, it's just an unsubstanciated claim.

And it's not the whole story of what's happening in practice. Several companies have been proven to download everything they can get a hold of and train their AIs on it. Pirated book archives, images they didn't obtain rights to. To the point where watermarks crept in and they had to add steps to their procedure to remove them and hide the fact. And Meta had to admit to pirating books. A proper analogy would be a professor who uses bittorrent and pirating sites to obtain material and hand that to their students to learn from... And that's not how it works in real life. Schools and universities license the material to distribute it to their students, put it in a library or the students have to buy the books. They don't rip off school-book authors per default.

And am I allowed to run bittorrent and download the latest Marvel movie (without paying) to watch it and "learn" what it's about? Download lots of music from P2P networks like I used to in the early 2000s? It'd save me the money I currently spend on a Spotify and Netflix subscription.