this post was submitted on 18 Jun 2023
15 points (94.1% liked)

Vintage Recipes - Archiving nostalgic recipes from cookbooks, handwritten notes, advertisements, etc

1627 readers
10 users here now

A community for sharing favorite vintage and nostalgic recipes from years past. The goal of this community is to preserve our favorite dishes and share them with the world so that they don't go extinct just because they're not in the culinary zeitgeist.

Please tag your recipe titles with [RECIPE]. Be sure to include the dish name and it’s creator (person or business) in the title for easier searching. Please include the date the recipe was published, if possible.

Sharing a video? Tag it with [VIDEO].

All requests should be tagged with [REQUEST]. Before you post, make sure someone hasn’t already requested the same recipe!

No recipe blog spam! You can link to a personal blog in the comments, but please include the recipe itself in your post. Any post URLs should point to the actual recipe (website, image host, etc.) and not just serve as an advertisement to drive up clicks for your site.

We here in Vintage Recipes believe that information should be freely available. We learn by observing and analyzing what has come before. We do not believe in secrets, and we do not believe that old methods should be forgotten.

founded 2 years ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
[–] [email protected] 1 points 2 years ago (1 children)

Understood it was dry beans, but for the volume of soup and flour-fat roux to thicken, seems like a fairly thin soup.

1 pound dry beans is about 2 cups, typically around 4-5 cups rehydrated and cooked.

When I make a large pot of soup for our family I would use about half that in beans.

[–] DocMcStuffin 1 points 2 years ago

Yeah. I see it as a side dish, and not looking that great of one. It's basically just beans, a little onion, and ham stock for the aromatics. This is one of those recipes where I would make modifications to. Adding tomatoes helps, but that's slightly acidic and will increase cook time with their current steps.

From the notes, it sounds like the flour is there to try and keep the beans suspended in the soup. It's not really much of a roux because there's no fat. Raw flour to a soup is kinda eiw. It can be done, but I tend to use corn starch as a thickener.