this post was submitted on 17 Sep 2023
131 points (87.9% liked)
Memes
487 readers
1 users here now
Good memes, bad memes, unite towards a united front.
founded 5 years ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
There weren't any capitalists around the time of Jesus' death. The word "Capitalist" refers to someone who extracts surplus value from labour by owning the capital - either machines and factories, or the financial means thereto - which workers operate. A capitalist can only exist in the context of industrialing or industrialised society, and there were no such societies during the Bronze Age.
I'm not sure about that, weren't nobles/landlords capitalists by extracting a rent from the 'working class'/laborers ?
No, obviously there were exploiters and rent-seekers during the Bronze Age, but capital has a distinct dynamic as opposed to other means of production such as land, namely that it can be expanded: A hectar of land in an agrarian society only produces so much grain, vegetables, or livestock every year, but the only upper limit for the production of machinery is the amount of available labour.
A land-owner can only expand at the expense of other land-owners, while capitalists also can - and are even required to - expand at the expense of the workers they employ. They use machinery and labour to obtain wealth and then use that to obtain more machinery, and so on. This arrangement has a dynamic of exponential growth, which no previous form of production had, and therefore capitalists are in a position to shape society in vast excess of what land-owners can and could do.
Landlording is not particular to capitalism, it is in fact a relic from past modes or production that continues in capitalism.
https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1847/11/prin-com.htm
I've never read that one, it's much better than the communist manifesto i.m.h.o., even if it's a bit too short to take into account any counter-argument, and it'd need an update almost 200 years later. I remember know that there's obviously a difference between the bourgeoisie and the nobility, but there must exist some kind of word encompassing both the nobles from the past and the modern bourgeoisie/capitalists. Anyway, here's a relevant quote i liked :
And, unrelated :
As well as :