this post was submitted on 11 Sep 2023
156 points (99.4% liked)
Ukraine
8368 readers
1055 users here now
News and discussion related to Ukraine
*Sympathy for enemy combatants is prohibited.
*No content depicting extreme violence or gore.
*Posts containing combat footage should include [Combat] in title
*Combat videos containing any footage of a visible human must be flagged NSFW
Server Rules
- Remember the human! (no harassment, threats, etc.)
- No racism or other discrimination
- No Nazis, QAnon or similar
- No porn
- No ads or spam (includes charities)
- No content against Finnish law
Donate to support Ukraine's Defense
Donate to support Humanitarian Aid
founded 2 years ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
Why do you think this is somehow super lethal?
And if it were, why is nobody using it much more?
Have you ever even been close to a big fire?
My house burnt down July 5th. You have no idea what yr talking about.
I got caught once on a highway in the mountains near a fire. I had to travel 30 miles on this road. I was apparently the last one to get on the road before the state closed it because the winds changed. I know this because I was stopped more than once and asked what I was doing, in a bewildered, exasperated way each time.
So you have a clear idea what it can be like, the highway was cleared of the forest for about 200ft off each side. The entirety of the last 10 miles was fire trucks and helicopters and planes flying over having just dropped water.
Im hauling ass right, no ones on the road anyway so I book it up to 70 and get the fuck out of there, that much activity, besides the smoke and embers hitting my car and you just don't want to be there, y'know.
The last couple miles the wind had pushed the fire to the edge of the forest. It's 3pm but the only light on me is from the fire. I have my headlights on. I'm looking over at the fire as the trucks start moving away, abandoning their positions and see 200ft tall Doug firs FUCKING EXPLODE
You have no idea what a forest fire is like. It's worse than you can even imagine, trust me.
This shit the Russians are doing is a crime against humanity. One of MANY there are doing in Ukraine.
There is no forest fire, there is hardly anything left to burn there. This stuff is generally not deadly and all the terrible effects people mention are made up. Hence my comment. That a forest fire can be absolutely devastating is no question at all.
This is what it looks like when it hits steel. The steel cools it down rapidly and it stops burning.
Here is a picture of ground that was hit. No burning through (into the ground) or anything. It just sits and burns.
This is what it looks like when trenches are hit.
They're incendiary munitions. They can literally burn you alive. Russia used loads of them on Ukrainian towns, expecially in the beginning of the war.
No, they can't. There is no physical way for a bit of magnesium (60 g?) to burn someone alive, even if we assume the person is already paralyzed and hence can't move at all while it sits and burns. It is simply not deadly and all the terrible effects people mention are made up.
This is what it looks like when it hits steel. The steel cools it down rapidly and it stops burning.
Here is a picture of ground that was hit. No burning through (into the ground) or anything. It just sits and burns.
This is what it looks like when trenches are hit.
Bro, there is literally a fire in that trench. If your clothes catch fire, you're going to have a bad day, unless the mighty russians have managed to find a way to make fires created by their incendiaries burn at a comfortable 25C only.
That looks like white phosphorous. It burns at 2500C and sticks to things and people.
@ours I constantly see it said that these are actually unlikely to be white phosphorus as a reply to the videos being labeled as such...
Anyone have a longer explanation or a link to one about the range of things these kinds of attacks can be and why they might or might not be white phosphorus when it is Russia doing it in Ukraine?
@ukraine
Burning white phosphorus (WP) releases a thick white smoke (P2O5 reacting with water in the air). So if there is no dense, white smoke, it can not be WP.
@Eheran Thanks, yeah I saw your other comments that provided informational links after posting this.
@ukraine
Could this be illumination rounds then? Would explain how the forest isn't actually on fire, the lack of smoke, and the non-chalantness of the video.
No, those are incendiary rounds, there just isn't much left to burn at this point. It looks amazing for a minute and then it is burned up.
these intense, devastating fires are happening around the globe. it fucks up everything when it happens. are you ok?
I am glad to tell you that it is not deadly and all the terrible effects people here mention are made up.
This is what it looks like when it hits steel. The steel cools it down rapidly and it stops burning.
Here is a picture of ground that was hit. No burning through (into the ground) or anything. It just sits and burns.
This is what it looks like when trenches are hit.
thank you.