this post was submitted on 01 Sep 2023
22 points (95.8% liked)
Apple TV+ Community
502 readers
1 users here now
This is a community for Apple TV+ discussions (the service, not the Apple TV device).
Here you can discuss news about shows, changes to the service and other matters.
New episodes of shows tend to drop at midnight UTC. Daylight savings may or may not shift this an hour.
Rules:
Spoilers:
- No spoilers
Civility:
- Always be respectful and be civil
- Remember the human
- Don't get baited by trolls, see someone be a dick, block/report and walk away
Piracy:
- Don't ask for or share any pirated material, this includes "clever" hints
Links:
- Don't editorialize links. Use the article's title as the title of your post
Off-topic:
- Keep posts and comments relevant to the service in general and news about new content
- Try to keep episode discussions in the relevant communities, you're free to (cross)post to/about episode discussion threads in relevant communities
- No tech support
Bootstrapping:
- For the time being, to bootstrap the community, crossposts of archived Reddit posts by the Lemmit bot that show up in [email protected] are allowed
- Try to be logical about crossposts
- Crossposting questions the answer to which would only specifically benefit the OP (who is on Reddit and can't read replies), is useless
- Crossposting questions that could lead to comments with information that would benefit members of the community are fine
- Lemmit crossposts need to be tagged with [Lemmit]
Other communities with related topics:
founded 1 year ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
So did I, but I just want the girls to take something from it. If all they do is escape with their lives, what was the point? It would be dope if Gaal Uno-reverses and absorbs Tellem, enhancing her own ability or something.
Ah right, yea I'm with you. The general idea seems that it will be part of the story of the second foundation, so yea, it'd definitely be disappointing if it ended up as a "well that sucked" story.
That being said, the revelation that Tallem (leader of the mentalics) is old and has been manipulating things from afar for a while was interesting and cool and maybe, along with establishing the whole mentalics thing instead of having them come out of nowhere, worth the visit.
Broadly speaking, the challenge of adapting the books into a TV show was how do you handle the time jumps and new characters as well as the complexity of what's happening. The show's obviously worked hard to get characters to persist over time, and largely, I'd say, done a better job than I ever thought it would. But, to my surprise, they've found a way to get the stories of these characters to create a pretty good sense of the complexities of the state and evolution of the galactic civilisation.
Empire, Gaal/Salvor, Hari-vault and Hari-main(?) along with the Mentalics and Demerzel on the side, are all trying to act with some sort of long time-scale perspective (maybe not Salvor so much, but it's probably not a coincidence that she's the most likeable character). At the moment, it's working as the core of a show in a post-game-of-thrones world, and, nicely, puts the show in a place to explore what psychohistory is and how it works in ways the books (well the original trilogy, I never read any of the others) never really gave themselves a chance to.