For a sub that’s supposed to promote Reddit alternatives, there sure is a lot of pessimism on there. I see so many people dismissing Lemmy and kbin already for being too inaccessible, the UI is clunky, it’s hard to pick up etc and saying these sites will never take off. But why? Of course a platform in its infancy will have hurdles to overcome, and it takes time for devs to implement all the QOL features to make the site more intuitive. And when I see people trying to explain how Lemmy works, people just respond “Too complicated, I’m not reading all that etc.”
Do people expect a fully functional Reddit clone with all the same features to conveniently exist somewhere they can hop to? Do people not realise that Reddit itself was just as confusing when users migrated from Digg all those years ago? Do they not realise sites take time to mature?
RedditAlternatives is the only subreddit I still use because I want to help people make the jump, but it’s kinda disheartening seeing the attitudes there. Anyone has a more optimistic take on this?
I just joined Lemmy 2 days ago and heard about it last week because of all the protest. I don’t find it unintuitive at all, but I can understand the confusion.
Most people want something simple. Going on Reddit all one needs to do (nowadays) is login -> login with <service_name> and boom that person just made an account.
On Lemmy you have to pick an instance -> choose which instance you want to join (which can be hard for some people or they can find it unintuitive) -> go to register and create an account (and sometimes wait for it to be accepted, or even answer questions before that. Although there are instances that don’t need all this stuff, the amount of choices can make it difficult). It might not look hard, but to someone that wants something simple and easy is probably not very good of an experience.
It took me a minute to figure it out 2 days ago and I don't think I'm a dummy, but who knows. That said, my "Reddit sort by top-> this hour" addiction is already well being fed and I'm happy.
What makes it hard isn't really about the federation, but that there are many internet users that haven't dealt with how the internet works outside of a top sites experience, but have an expectation set. The complaint is literally "I am illiterate about this and it's your fault".
This is something you will see a lot of in gaming Let's Plays as the first time player bitches for the first 5-10 minutes about how nothing makes sense. Then they run into an interaction they like and shut up for the rest of the playthrough.
That’s what turned me off from Lemmy. I had no clue what I was doing to begin with, then I tried to register for an instance, and the sign up button just kept spinning forever. So I tried another instance. It wanted me to type out why I wanted to join and answer some questions. Like, what? I’m not jumping through hoops to use your service. Plus, as far as I’m aware, your username you register with on one instance doesn’t follow you into other instances. It makes zero sense to me.
It’s Like signing up for a gmail account. You can email yahoo accounts, but your username won’t work to log into yahoo.
I went though the same issues as you. I was able to get a lemmy account and a kbin, and fedia account. Now kbin has enable federation, and the feed is muchhhhh more active. The traffic to the sites have slowed down a bit and they have mostly scaled up their servers. Works great for me now.
It's not quite that simple though. It would be like if Yahoo email users weren't able to see emails from GMail users in some cases. Like beehaw people can't see posts from us lemmy.world users.
An understandable but imo misguided decision. I am on Kbin so we're not affected yet but it's a bad precedent to set in this time of growth for defederation imo. It erodes trust in instances that practice it.
Agreed completely. I know beehaw has been around a while and they have a "brand" and "vision" they're trying to push, but the timing could be better. This stuff will sort itself out as new tools become available, and the more people using the Fediverse the faster those tools will be developed.
I disagree, I think it's still pretty solid comparison. Some email servers are blacklisted entirely by others and emails originating from those won't come in. That's not a very common thing but it does happen.