Red Devils

934 readers

2 users here now

All things Manchester United.

New to the community? Come say hi in the Welcome thread.

Got any suggestions on how we can improve and grow as a community? Let us know!

Basic rules:

Fuck the Glazers
Be civil to each other
No non-Manchester United/football content. Non-United content is allowed if it affects United in some way. Otherwise, use the Daily Discussion Thread
Fuck the Glazers
Before posting news, please refer to the Journalist Reliability Guide
Keep it legal - no streams please :)
Have fun!
Fuck the Glazers

founded 2 years ago

MODERATORS

[Hirt/Duncker -T1] Man United close to Patrick Dorgu deal as Amorim hints at Casemiro exit (www.thetimes.com)

submitted 1 week ago by kameecoding to c/reddevils

4 comments fedilink hide all child comments

you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments

[–] designated_fridge 1 points 1 week ago (1 children)

We are probably walking a very thin line in terms of PSR. Usually we never spend in January, and never long-term? Spending this amount of money - in January - reeks of desperation imo. The form is horrible and the team doesn't seem to be improving under Amorim.

At the same time, the reasoning for sacking EtH was that the earlier the pain of transition starts - the better. But there has to be some highlights to justify that pain and we are not seeing it right now so the leadership is now desperate to give Amorim more tools to improve things because in the end - if they sacked the manager and hired a new one (which undeniably is a great manager - I have nothing against Amorim) and we end up in a horrible position with no leverage in the summer window and a squad depleted of motivation after finishing 14th... Then were does that leave us? Then it's hard to argue that sacking EtH was the right choice... Or RvN if you so like (i.e. going with RvN for the rest of the season)

Can't imagine we'd spend this amount at this point of the season otherwise.

[–] kameecoding 1 points 1 week ago* (last edited 1 week ago)

I think you are reading too much into this, 30 million on a 5 year contract is 6 million a year (in euros), or 120K a week, anthony on loan frees up 85K pounds a week alone, if dorgu is signed then malacia can be loaned out too.and whitwell mentioned that with Maguire getting his contract extended his remaining book value will be amortized over more years too.

I think this is simply United buying another player that's young and promising and can play in multiple positions a good pickup regardless of the manager, but letting ETH and Ruud go was not a bad choice, if anything not letting ETH go kn the summer was the wrong choice