this post was submitted on 13 Jan 2025
864 points (99.1% liked)
US Authoritarianism
915 readers
491 users here now
ChonkyOwlbear is an Illegitimate Usurper
There's other groups and you are welcome to add to them. USAuthoritarianism Linktree
See Also, my website. USAuthoritarianism.com be advised at time of writing it is basically just a donate link
Cool People: [email protected]
founded 10 months ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
I think this is very true, but how do we organize a society around science? Science can tell us many important things, but it can't necessarily tell us what we should value or what is moral. There are very intelligent, educated people trying to develop moral and ethical frameworks, using critical thinking and reasoning, but how do we ensure those frameworks become the basis for society? Even in a democracy, the people can choose to adopt those moral and ethical frameworks (assuming the people are even aware they exist), but they can also choose not to. Of course that's true of any ruler, so I'm not saying that's unique to democracy, but I'm just saying that democracy doesn't necessarily solve the problem of rulers ruling unethically.
There's technocracy, but for a technocracy to function, wouldn't the technocrats need to have a fairly significant amount of power? I don't necessarily think that technocracy is completely antithetical to democracy, but the technocrats would need the authority to override the people, whenever the people would try to implement some policy that was unscientific, making the technocrats, not the people, the ultimate authority.
This is why the older I get, the more cynical I become about democracy. People are easily frightened herd animals who often refuse to look past the surface level shiny veneer. It always devolves. Every single democracy in history falls prey to the populist who takes advantage of this human weakness.
The modern globalist system has left you out of the manufacturing job you expected to have? Are you frightened about your financial future and your children's future? Here, I have a solution for you. We will build a wall and deport the brown people. It's all their fault. Please ignore the man behind the curtain.
Instead of us having an educated populace that sees through the wool being pulled over their eyes, they instead put their heads in the sand and choose to full-send into whatever right-wing ideology is thrown their way. It happened before, it will happen again.
The superior system, I think, would look something like the Chinese although they are not perfect by any means.
What they do is in primary school, they test the children and see who has a strong aptitude. They take these children out of the normal class and groom them to be party leaders. These party leaders then eventually end up as the leaders in the future. China actually is a pseudo-democracy- it's just that only party members get to vote. And there are actually over 2 million party members. But the difference there is that it's more of a meritocracy. There is still nepotism and whatnot, but the leaders slowly rise up over time based on results.
Look at Xi Jinping for example
The way it works is you start in a lower spot and work your way up slowly over time. And he was actually destined for failure due to his father being a "traitor"
But his results ended up pushing him to the top anyway.
This sort of meritocratic technocratic society will always win out over our populist oligarchy. And to the doubters, consider that our system is not any less elitist.
Instead of testing children and grooming them for leadership, we do it based on last name and wealth. If your parents went to Harvard, you grow up with tutors and extracurriculars and all the support you could want. Then you are groomed for success by joining an Ivy League school, you join some sort of fraternity that presidents were a part of and you meet the future senators and CEOs.
It's the same thing except instead of results and meritocracy- it's more influenced by wealth and nepotism.
Of course I'm not claiming the Chinese system is somehow ideal, but I believe democracy is fatally flawed. Plato wrote about this in "The Republic" already countless years ago. Ironically, in his ideal Republic (which to be fair is sort of a dystopia) they actually groom capable children like the Chinese do for party leadership.
Maybe we can just develop generalized artificial intelligence and have it run our society for us. I'd have more faith in the AI than I do in our congress.