this post was submitted on 15 Jun 2023
8 points (100.0% liked)
toki pona
207 readers
2 users here now
toki! ni li kulupu sin pi toki pona lon lipu Lemi!
Rules
- Instance-wide rules apply.
- Be nice and treat others the way you want to be treated.
- Posts must be in, about or linked to toki pona in some way.
- Prefer using toki pona or English, and mark posts in toki pona as English.*
- Please don't behave in a way that would require of writing more rules.
*: posts in "Undetermined language" may not show up for many people, nor posts in languages that the user didn't select in their settings. Later this rule may change, but until we have a steady flow of content, it would be good to have everything as visible and accessible as possible.
founded 1 year ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
I don't think there will be a standardized list of all the place names. mi pilin e ni: jan mute li kama sona e toki pona la nasin jan en nasin kalama li ken ante.
What may be interesting to see is how each country's speaker would tokiponize their own stuff. I know jan Sonja called my country ma Malasija in lipu pu, but I would naturally sound more as ma Malesija, and I know that jan poka mi li pilin sama.
ma Mosijo for Hungary is objectively terrible as far as transliterations go, though I quote like that it's one of the very few if not only that changed very early on (2005 iirc -- it was Masija, which was too similar to Asija).
The 'gy' /ɟ~ɟ͡ʝ/ in magyar* becoming an /s/ is just weird, though can be reasoned (/ɟ~ɟ͡ʝ/ > /dʲ/ > /di/ > /ti/ >** /si/ -- the semivowel then added back), it's still one syllable too long. 'a' is an /ɒ/ in Hungarian, that becoming an 'o' is arguably acceptable (although I'd argue against it, but given the circumstances, I won't complain).
Better solution? "Mata" for Hungarian could work I guess, all I know is that U'd greatly orefer having a plosive in it than a fricative.
*: the country's name is Magyarország, where magyar=Hungarian, ország=country **: by toki pona syllable rules