99
No one should have to “grow a thicker skin”: Valorant studio commit to harsh penalties for harassment
(www.rockpapershotgun.com)
this post was submitted on 05 Jun 2024
99 points (92.3% liked)
Gaming
20076 readers
63 users here now
Sub for any gaming related content!
Rules:
- 1: No spam or advertising. This basically means no linking to your own content on blogs, YouTube, Twitch, etc.
- 2: No bigotry or gatekeeping. This should be obvious, but neither of those things will be tolerated. This goes for linked content too; if the site has some heavy "anti-woke" energy, you probably shouldn't be posting it here.
- 3: No untagged game spoilers. If the game was recently released or not released at all yet, use the Spoiler tag (the little ⚠️ button) in the body text, and avoid typing spoilers in the title. It should also be avoided to openly talk about major story spoilers, even in old games.
founded 5 years ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
Given the choice between an online community with assholes being moderated away and an online community without asshole moderation, I'm going to choose the one where assholes get warned, muted, and banned.
My favourite subreddit had a rule, "Be Civil". I much preferred that sub over ones that didn't have that rule (or one like it). Too many people don't know how to behave in public forums, and those people make the internet a lot less pleasant. See Facebook and Instagram comments if you'd like some examples.
I don't play many online games, except with friends exclusively, or where there is no chat (especially voice chat). If there were games that had moderated communities that banned assholes, then I'd be more likely to venture into that world...and maybe I'd even start turning on my mic.
A competitive gaming community is different. You want players who are invested in winning. It's more fun when everyone is playing hard. I'd rather have someone yell at someone who threw a round than no one say anything and have that player throw more rounds.
People are so coddled these days they have all the tools at their disposal to avoid "toxic" behavior and yet they won't mute the person and will complain as if there was nothing they could do to escape the harassment of words on a screen. If someone is taking getting to you then you can mute them.
As for your statement on toxicity preventing you from playing multiplayer doesn't seem true. There are plenty of games where you will never see toxicity and you still don't play any of them so that can't be what's stopping you.
Yes. Players who are invested in winning. Not players who have poor emotional regulation or social behaviour and are invested in being assholes.
It's called sportsmanship. Yet some online games sound worse than middle school sports games... probably because, for years, nobody got punished for acting like a middle schooler who can't control their emotions or behaviour.
I'm fascinated by how you know so much about the games I don't play! Lol
You said you don't play many online games with Randoms because there aren't games that moderate their communities. But there are plenty of games that moderate their communities so how is that hindering you from playing? It seems you just prefer to play single player or multi-player with friends. Which is fine but you are speaking about distrastically changing the culture of a community you don't even interact with on the slim chance that they entice you to join.
To your point on sportsman ship. Yeah I would prefer if every good player was not a dickhead but I care about teammate skill before team mate attitude. When you are playing competitive games it wastes everyone's time to play dumb or play wrong. If someone joins a ranked cs lobby and tries to only knife they deserve to get flamed. As long as people aren't breaking the rules regarding hate speech I don't care how mean or rude players are in competitive play. I personally don't flame but I don't mind that others do it raises the stakes and puts pressure on players which is a good thing. When I get flamed and I feel it's annoying I just mute the person and continue.
I've played games that overly moderate the communities speech and it leads to not one talking and it feels like playing single player as everyone may as well be a bot.
Hate speech and threats of violence are what the article is about.
So if you agree that rape threats and certain words (that constitute hate speech) are ok to ban, then you're in agreement with the article and other people saying "People shouldn't need to grow a thicker skin".
Unless you're against hate speech, but in favour of threats of violence, but I don't think you are just because you didn't explicitly say it, haha
I'll try to be more specific about why I disagree cause I think my original comment did a poor job.
The article is basically someone tweeting an extreme situation at riot games acting like they so nothing about that kind of behavior. That's not true I'd bet my left nut that guy would have been banned if the player had just muted him and reported him. They say oh i cant mute because then i need to communicate as if they have any need to communicate with a player making those kind of threats. It doesn't make sense even with 100% perfect moderation you should would still need to mute the player and report.
Riot then is forced to respond by increasing how much they moderate speech. Introducing a bunch of new moderation and saying trust us guys we understand banter and won't go overboard. But that's exactly what will happen with all these extra tools and people start moderating. the bar for what is considered mutable will keep lowering. As long as this mentality of "never mute anyone and ban anyone who upsets you" continues then moderators will cater to their thinnest skinned players. At some point you need to realize you have to mute players who upset you and not engage with them.
In league of legends you get banned for saying anything remotely offensive it's why no one talks in-game anymore. For a real life example ive been muted for saying "ok sex havers". Here's a reddit thread where many people have experienced the same over the top moderation that I describe.
If you want to kill communication in your game this is the right step to take. Reactionary measures are never a good sign. At someone point people need to mute and move and let valorant moderate their game without every toxic moment treated as common.
League is not toxic in communication anymore it's toxic in players mentality and intent to ruin the game but it will never outgrow the toxic rep it earned thus people will treat every instance of toxicity like a common event.
After writing this all out I think I've convinced myself out of my position but I'll leave the rough draft of what i wrote. Maybe you're right that more moderation is a good thing. I can see chat being over moderated from the increased scrutiny. I can't see a world where competitive multi-player games are a safe space for all types of people. Muting will always be necessary to curate your online experience.