Any ideas what I might be missing/doing wrong? ๐ญ
Turns out this was 100% my own brain fart - I HAD already completed the cabinet, which is why doing it over and over wasn't doing anything, and it was the next quest I was looking for and missing (the guide was saying go by the brook, and for whatever reason I thought I WAS even though now I think about it I obviously wasn't) ๐๐๐
Found it now, and have already completed the next one.
Leaving this up in case anyone else is oblivious enough to make the same mistake I did, however unlikely that is ๐