Can we interact with BookWyrm from kbin.social?
this post was submitted on 15 Jun 2023
16 points (100.0% liked)
Books
526 readers
1 users here now
founded 1 year ago
I honestly don't know. I only just found out about BookWyrm from that post on Mastodon. Interestingly, the text of the toot was autoposted into the text box when I put the link into the link box. That text is from Rambling Readers! I don't want to misattribute things.
That said, I think there's a chance. It would probably show up in the "Microblog" portion of the magazine. That is setup to pick up on hashtags in the Fediverse and so if BookWyrm federated made a post that had a particular hashtag, it might show up here.
But in short, I simply am unsure all the intricacies of the fediverse here. I've really only interacted with Mastodon up to this point (and it's gone well)
@Remillard @bookstodon @Rainbright Hashtags on #Bookwyrm don't seem to work properly, unless that has been fixed. In theory though it ought to work as you say. Default hashtags for certain Bookwyrm events might be good too. I've not posted to Bookwyrm since following my account from kbin, so not sure how it works there.
I'll have to give it some time and see how things shake out. There are some growing pains with the Fediverse but I'd love a Goodreads alternative.
@Rainbright @bookstodon @Remillard @confusedbunny I was looking for a Goodreads alternative because I kind of cringe at the thought of Amazon getting more of my data than it already has. I landed on #TheStoryGraph. While I haven't had time to do a deep dive, I've been liking what I've seen so far. The export from Goodreads was pretty simple.
I don't know if that's the answer you're looking for - It's not part of the Fediverse - but at least it's not making Jeff Bezos richer. #Bookstodon
@dbsalk @Rainbright @bookstodon @Remillard @confusedbunny Just to add another option. :)
I like Bookwyrm and Storygraph (use both because I too am on the hunt for a GR alternative) but am really liking Hardcover.app.
@jwilker @dbsalk @Rainbright @bookstodon @Remillard @confusedbunny I, too, use Storygraph, but I'll check out #Bookwyrm
I'm on StoryGraph too (and BookWyrm), but I've been burned WAY too often by profiteers. GoodReads in particular is seared into my memory; their owners lied to users to get tens of thousands of free hours of labor out of us (to "save GoodReads from Amazon"), all while they were negotiating to sell out to Amazon! And then Amazon immediately started censoring and shadowbanning reviews to suit their corporate bottom line.
I've seen far too many great digital communities destroyed by greedy vulture capitalists. I'm done. If a service has a single owner - plutocrat or corporation - it automatically goes to the bottom of the list. I'll stick with BookWyrm, thanks! It may be a little light on features so far, but I'd rather put my work in there and wait for improvements.
@Rainbright @bookstodon @Remillard Bookwyrm works fantastically as a GoodReads alternative! It just doesn't federate quite as well as it could (across different platforms), but that's no big deal. I can read, follow, etc from Mastodon no problem, Takahē misses some posts, and I've not tried from kbin yet (the instance I'm on is having federation issues).
Giving it a try. Import is slow, but I have ~1500 between my read and want to read lists so I can't blame anyone for that.
Edit: importing isn't too bad, but constructing lists is brutal. It was bad enough on goodreads with the list view, but this is untenable. It appears the only way to do it is to manually search for every title you want to add.
Just came across BookWyrm myself. If anyone could link a how to or something. That would be great. Right now, I feel like I am just cataloging books and no real discovery is happening.
Discovery seems limited to the books the people on that instance are reading. I don't think much discovery will be happening on this site.
Did Amazon always own Good Reads? Or did they acquire it?
@Gargleblaster @bookstodon @Remillard Amazon acquired GoodReads back in 2013
https://techcrunch.com/2013/03/28/amazon-acquires-social-reading-site-goodreads/
@Gargleblaster @bookstodon @Remillard
Amazon bought Goodreads in 2013.
https://www.theguardian.com/books/2013/apr/02/amazon-purchase-goodreads-stuns-book-industry
view more: next ›