this post was submitted on 14 Jan 2024
22 points (92.3% liked)
BecomeMe
753 readers
1 users here now
Social Experiment. Become Me. What I see, you see.
founded 1 year ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
Well it's not like our planet allows open air smelting either. Sure you can get a fire going, but blast furnaces still need oxygen enrichment.
That and this assumes that in the face of a different challenge another solution wouldn’t arise.
Our technology formed because of the problems we had and the ways we worked around them and iterated on that. Necessity is the mother of invention.
Idunno. There are some things that can be safely assumed. It's a safe assumption that without access to fire, you can't cook food. You can't easily work metal without fire, which rules out virtually all technological progress past the stone age, if we can even make it to the stone age without cooking.
You can say there might be workarounds and other methods, but you can also say that maybe some things see with dark instead of light. Just because you can hypothesize doesn't mean those hypotheses are potentially right.
Suuuuuper interesting line of reasoning. I think this opens other questions that can help to clarify and better understand where some of the great filters live. We got to space travel and radio communications with the conditions and resources available to us here on Earth. I've heard scientists speculate as to whether life could develop on cold worlds in oceans of methane, but never heard about what sorts of technologies could be possible on drastically different planets. Maybe life could develop in a very different way but technologies hitting some real ceilings depending on what's available. We see even here on Earth, animals with fantastic intelligence such as dolphins that A) never had an evolutionary pressure to develop tool building extremities and B) didn't have the same access to naturally transformable resources as we did. Understanding where these technological ceilings are based on the resources available on a planet could really inform how many other space capable civilizations are out there. Or at the very least, help us to specify how some of these great filters are arranged.