this post was submitted on 03 Oct 2024
8 points (100.0% liked)

College Football

847 readers
30 users here now

A community to discuss college football.

Find your team's community

Join the Fanaticus Discord

Vote in the community poll

/c/CFB Poll Top 25 Fanaticus
1. ~~Ohio State~~ Ohio State
2. Oregon Oregon
3. Texas Texas
4. Notre Dame Notre Dame
T-5. Georgia Georgia
T-5. Penn State Penn State
7. SMU SMU
8. ~~Miami~~ Miami
9. Indiana Indiana
10. Tennessee Tennessee
11. South Carolina South Carolina
12. ~~Clemson~~ Clemson
13. Boise State Boise State
14. Arizona State Arizona State
15. Ole Miss Mississippi
T-16. Alabama Alabama
T-16. Iowa State Iowa State
T-16. ~~Tulane~~ Tulane
19. BYU BYU
20. Army Army
21. ~~Texas A&M~~ Texas A&M
22. Colorado Colorado
23. Illinois Illinois
24. UNLV UNLV
25. ~~Kansas State~~ Kansas State

Check out our other sports communities!

founded 1 year ago
MODERATORS
8
submitted 1 month ago* (last edited 1 month ago) by g0d0fm15ch13f to c/[email protected]
 
Place Team Points #1 Votes Movement
1 Texas 98 2 -
2 alabama 97 2 +1
3 Tennessee 90 0 -1
4 Oregon 80 0 +9
4 Penn State 80 0 +7
6 Ohio State 78 0 -1
7 Miami (FL) 75 0 -3
8 Missouri 54 0 +11
9 Iowa State 50 0 +12
10 Michigan 45 0 -1
11 BYU 44 0 +7
11 Indiana 44 0 +14
11 UNLV 44 0 NR
14 LSU 43 0 +6
14 Notre Dame 43 0 -4
16 USC 33 0 -4
17 Clemson 32 0 -2
18 Georgia 30 0 -11
19 Ole Miss 28 0 -14
20 Oklahoma 27 0 -6
21 Illinois 19 0 +2
22 James Madison 18 0 NR
23 Kentucky 17 0 NR
24 Duke 15 0 NR
24 Pittsburgh 15 0 NR

Dropped out: Louisville (7), South Carolina (3), Utah(NV), Georgia Tech (NV), Liberty (NV)

Others receiving votes: Rutgers (14), Texas Tech (12), Colorado (10), Kansas State (9), Arizona (8), Boise State (7), Louisville (7), Utah (7), Army (6), Kent State (6), Navy (6), Nebraska (6), South Carolina (3)

Link to the results spreadsheet HERE

Link for next weeks poll HERE

Link to submit your CFP bracket prediction for the contest HERE

top 7 comments
sorted by: hot top controversial new old
[–] [email protected] 3 points 1 month ago

Dropped out: Louisville (7), South Carolina (3), Georgia Tech (NV), Liberty (NV)

Looks like you forgot about Utah, which plummeted from 8th to unranked (T31). Oof... They're not garbage, they're just waiting for Cam Rising to come back! "Trust me bro, he'll be good to go next week" --Kyle Whittingham, probably

[–] [email protected] 3 points 1 month ago

I blame all the chaos on myself. I didn't have time to put together a poll this week.

I have 2 big takeaways.
First, we really don't have the clarity I thought we would 4/5 games into the season. We have such an even balance of presumed weaker teams that are undefeated, and presumed strong teams with a loss, that I can't make any of it out. Roughly teams 9-35 all have legitimate claims that they should be ranked in the top 15. I know that this is supposed to get clearer every week, but it hasn't. I feel more unsure every week.

Second, Boise State is is the most devalued team in our poll. That team looks very good right now. With the rest of their schedule, UNLV is the only ranked game I see the rest of the way. It is possible they don't move up very much. It really is a loss to a top 4 team hurting them (but I guess Ole Miss and Georgia have the same complaint right now).

[–] g0d0fm15ch13f 3 points 1 month ago* (last edited 1 month ago) (1 children)

To the naked eye:

  • Lots of movement in the top 10. I knew there was chaos last week, but I think the domino effect was pretty major in most ballots
  • Missouri jumps 11 spots? For what? For not almost losing to Vandy 2 weeks in a row? They were on a bye y'all
  • Ole Miss drops 14 for losing to an unranked Kentucky (they still poll above the Wildcats), seems fair.
  • Georgia drops 11 spots for losing to the third ranked tide though? (Georgia was ranked 7th when they played)
  • Reports of UNLV's death were greatly exaggerated.
  • UNLV and Indiana just about earned a banner spot along with BYU, hang in there y'all
  • UT BOWL IS OFF
  • Penn State and Oregon finally earning some votes after a sluggish start to their respective seasons
  • Illinois gets a quality win, moving up 2 spots after losing
  • Army & Navy both getting votes, hopefully setting us up for an awesome game at the end of the season (Go Navy, Beat Army!)
[–] WVbrU 4 points 1 month ago* (last edited 1 month ago) (2 children)

Yeah, Georgia's drop is in part due to my poll. It's my first week submitting and my computer poll is really down on Georgia atm. I think it has them in the low 30's right now.

[–] g0d0fm15ch13f 1 points 1 month ago* (last edited 1 month ago)

Don't confuse my bewilderment at the statistics with displeasure at the results lol, I ain't a fan of the dogs these days. Happy to have your ballot!

[–] [email protected] 1 points 1 month ago

No worries! I've been submitting a computer poll in past weeks and missed it this week, so the overall poll is probably not too imbalanced. Mine also has Georgia low (had them 40 last week and they kept that spot this week).

More data is always better, so I'll make sure to get mine in next week and hope even more join in!

[–] [email protected] 2 points 1 month ago* (last edited 1 month ago)

Sorry to have missed this one! I've been so swamped with work and personal stuff at the same time I haven't been able to keep up with CFB as much as I'd like. ~~It is nice to see a presumably all-human poll, though.~~ (edit: nevermind, I just read the other comments)

I'll update the banner and sidebar shortly.

FWIW, this is what my ballot (purely a computer ranking) would have been:

::: spoiler Full ranking:

Rank Change Team Record Points
1 - Texas 5-0 407
2 - Notre Dame 4-1 338
3 +7 Alabama 4-0 323
4 +7 Ohio State 4-0 309
5 -1 Ole Miss 4-1 305
6 -1 Miami (FL) 5-0 302
7 +1 Indiana 5-0 296
8 +7 Kentucky 3-2 292
9 - BYU 5-0 289
10 +1 Oklahoma 4-1 284
11 +10 Penn State 4-0 271
12 -10 Tennessee 4-0 270
13 +7 USC 3-1 269
14 +11 Nebraska 4-1 265
15 +15 SMU 4-1 264
T16 +2 Michigan 4-1 256
T16 -1 Virginia Tech 2-3 256
18 -4 Boston College 4-1 255
T19 +15 LSU 4-1 249
T19 +5 Cincinnati 3-2 249
21 +21 Clemson 3-1 247
22 -16 Georgia Tech 3-2 245
T23 -8 Utah 4-1 243
T23 +32 Colorado 4-1 243
T23 -16 South Carolina 3-1 243
T23 -5 Maryland 3-2 243
27 +21 Kansas State 4-1 241
28 -6 Illinois 4-1 240
T29 +4 Duke 5-0 235
T29 -2 Sam Houston 4-1 235
31 +7 Washington 3-2 230
T32 +33 UNLV 4-0 227
T32 +39 JMU 4-0 227
T34 +10 Texas A&M 4-1 226
T34 +5 Arkansas 3-2 226
T36 +8 Memphis 4-1 224
T36 +22 TCU 3-2 224
T38 +6 Texas Tech 4-1 223
T38 -10 Oklahoma State 3-2 223
T40 +31 Iowa State 4-0 221
T40 - Georgia 3-1 221
T40 -27 Arizona State 3-1 221
T40 +35 Connecticut 3-2 221
44 +21 Tulane 3-2 219
T45 -14 Washington State 4-1 214
T45 -1 Baylor 2-3 214
47 +8 Minnesota 2-3 213
48 +4 Auburn 2-3 207
49 +22 Eastern Michigan 4-1 205
50 +15 North Carolina 3-2 204
51 +29 UNT 4-1 203
T52 +35 Oregon 4-0 200
T52 -30 Missouri 4-0 200
T52 -11 Florida State 1-4 200
T55 +28 Army 4-0 197
T55 +14 Louisville 3-1 197
T57 -32 Pittsburgh 4-0 193
T57 +21 Rutgers 4-0 193
T57 +5 Kansas 1-4 193
60 -32 Iowa 3-1 191
T61 +45 Arizona 3-1 189
T61 -25 Fresno State 3-2 189
T61 +16 Northern Illinois 2-2 189
T64 +22 Navy 4-0 188
T64 -16 Michigan State 3-2 188
66 -35 Toledo 3-1 187
67 +13 ECU 3-2 186
68 -6 Houston 1-4 184
69 -35 Northwestern 2-2 183
T70 +14 Western Kentucky 3-2 182
T70 +12 FIU 2-3 182
72 -35 California 3-1 180
T73 +16 Boise State 3-1 178
T73 -14 South Alabama 2-3 178
T75 +18 Ohio 3-2 171
T75 -33 Nevada 2-3 171
T77 -16 Syracuse 3-1 170
T77 +7 Texas State 2-2 170
79 +19 Louisiana 3-1 169
80 -30 Vanderbilt 2-2 168
T81 -30 Liberty 4-0 164
T81 +20 Georgia Southern 3-2 164
T83 -31 San Jose State 3-1 163
T83 -31 Virginia 3-1 163
85 -6 UCF 3-1 162
86 -10 FAU 2-3 161
T87 -30 Coastal Carolina 3-1 160
T87 -23 Buffalo 3-2 160
T87 +6 Old Dominion 1-3 160
90 +3 Miami (OH) 1-3 157
91 -32 Oregon State 3-1 156
92 - Troy 1-4 153
93 -3 Mississippi State 1-4 152
94 -29 Florida 2-2 151
95 +4 Central Michigan 3-2 150
96 -26 West Virginia 2-2 149
97 +8 NC State 3-2 148
T98 -27 Jacksonville State 1-3 147
T98 +1 Bowling Green 1-3 147
100 +9 New Mexico 1-4 146
101 -8 Stanford 2-2 143
102 -15 USF 2-3 140
103 +5 Rice 1-4 136
104 -13 Tulsa 2-3 135
105 -1 UCLA 1-3 132
106 -9 Temple 1-4 131
T107 +5 Louisiana Tech 1-3 130
T107 +6 Massachusetts 1-4 130
109 +7 Charlotte 2-3 127
110 +11 UL Monroe 3-1 126
111 +14 Wyoming 1-4 123
112 -3 Georgia State 2-2 122
113 +11 Marshall 2-2 120
T114 +4 Wisconsin 2-2 119
T114 - UTSA 2-3 119
T114 +5 Wake Forest 1-3 119
117 +9 San Diego State 1-3 114
118 +5 New Mexico State 1-4 110
119 -17 Arkansas State 2-2 106
T120 -17 Hawaii 2-2 105
T120 -6 UAB 1-3 105
122 +5 Air Force 1-3 104
T123 -16 Colorado State 2-2 97
T123 +6 Western Michigan 1-3 97
125 -14 UTEP 0-4 94
126 -5 Kennesaw State 0-4 88
127 +3 Middle Tennessee 1-4 85
128 -12 Utah State 1-3 83
T129 -10 Appalachian State 2-2 81
T129 +4 Purdue 1-3 81
131 +1 Akron 1-4 80
132 -5 Southern Mississippi 1-3 71
133 +1 Kent State 0-5 64
134 -4 Ball State 1-3 59